Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
Wayfair has become a household name in the home decorating and furniture space over the past few years. Their claim to fame is their fast shipping and wide variety of affordable brands and products. However, with a wide variety of products, there is a wide variety of qualities, sometimes with lower quality options being the more widely sold. When it comes to their mattresses, many offerings are affordable and offer initial comfort, but there are some that had issues with durability. Despite that, their 100 night trial is a great bonus for a retailer of their size!
Wayfair has a wide array of mattress options all that come with 100 day trials, which is quite a high amount for traditional mattress retailers that sell multiple brands. Wayfair's selection is mostly focused on budget-conscious varieties, though they also have some options that are more expensive, such as those from Tempur-Pedic and other name brands. Overall, customers like what Wayfair has to offer in terms of customer service and pricepoint, but there are some that had issues with durability from some of the brands. Others had some disagreements about quality with some options.
Read on to learn more about their selection...or browse our top rated alternatives.
Wayfair has multiple options at competitive pricepoints from their own brands, like Nora and Wayfair Sleep™, and also higher end options from brands like Tempur-Pedic and Simmons Beautyrest.
We'll walk through each of the options below to help guide you in your decision.
So here they are...
Nora is a mattress brand that is exclusively sold at Wayfair. They have two options -- an all-foam version and a hybrid mattress that is better equipped for stomach sleepers and those looking for a firmer feel. While most customers like their Nora mattresses at first, there are some that had issues with the durability of the mattresses with quicker than average sagging issues reported.
The pros: Affordable mattresses for the materials used.
The cons: Some issues with durability reported by some sleepers.
Price Range: $329-$746
Final Score: 9.2 / 10
#2 Wayfair Sleep™
Wayfair Sleep is only sold at Wayfair's online stores. Their claim to fame is ultra-affordable mattresses that come in both hybrid and memory foam options. Their mattresses come in multiple thickness and firmness options. While most describe these mattresses as comfortable at first, there are some that had issues with long term comfort and quality. Some describe sagging issues and quality control problems with some models.
The pros: Wide array of hybrid and all-foam mattresses for extremely affordable prices.
The cons: Some issues with durability and quality control issues reported.
Price Range: $89-$569
Final Score: 9.1 / 10
Tempur-Pedic is one of the most well-known mattress brands available. It is well-known for its memory foam focused mattresses that are high end and high priced. They now offer mattresses that come with pocketed coils as well, and all of their mattresses come in a variety of firmness options. While most customers like their Tempur-Pedic mattresses at first, they are much higher priced for the materials, and some have had issues with durability on some models.
Price Range: $1019-$4899
Final Score: 8.9 / 10
Naturepedic is a popular brand among parents, with their high quality latex and all-natural mattresses that are designed for those that are sensitive to chemicals. Their mattresses come with both all-natural and organic latex options and those that rely on innersprings and cotton construction. While most customers like what goes in to their Naturepedic mattresses, some found the comfort to be an issue -- with the most common complaint being that the mattress is too firm.
The pros: A wide array of all-natural mattress options with a focus on sensitive sleepers.
The cons: Some problems with firmness and comfort for some. Can be expensive.
Price Range: $899-$2999
Final Score: 8.9 / 10
#5 Simmons Beautyrest
Simmons Beautyrest is one of the most well-known spring style mattress companies, with a focus on their fluffy top layers and multiple firmness options. Their mattresses come in a wide array of pricepoints and thickness options, that most customers like. Their mattresses feature thick layers of foam and some luxury features with the higher priced options. While many liked their Beautyrest mattresses at first, there are some that had issues with sagging and durability with some models, even those that were priced high.
The pros: High profile hybrid mattresses known for their high-end pillowy top layers.
The cons: Some durability complaints reported by sleepers. Some designs are expensive.
Price Range: $463-$5239
Final Score: 8.4 / 10
#6 Alwyn Home
Alwyn Home is a budget furniture brand that is popularly sold on online budget retailers like Wayfair and others. They have a wide variety of offerings -- from all-foam to traditional innerspring designs. With prices that start at less than $200, customers feel good about finding a deal. However, there have been some issues reported about some offerings. Specifically, there are some customers that had issues with the quality of the mattresses -- with some reporting quick sagging and initial depressions. Others wished for additional layers of comfort.
The pros: Very affordable mattresses with multiple design options.
The cons: Some problems with quality reported by some sleepers.
Price Range: $80-$1289
Final Score: 7.7 / 10
Sealy is one of the most well-known brands, made famous for their zoned coil spring mattresses that work with the back to keep the posture aligned. They offer both budget and higher end offerings, with Wayfair's selection mostly focusing on the lower priced options. Most customers like the Sealy mattresses at first, but some had issues with durability and initial feel for some models.
The pros: Wide selection of spring mattresses with multiple pricepoints available.
The cons: Some lower priced models have issues reported about durability and initial comfort.
Price Range: $129-$2424
Final Score: 7.3 / 10
Serta is widely known for its iComfort brand with thick layers of foam on the top layers reinforced by special core foam or pocketed coils. Their mattresses come in many different pricepoints and thickness levels with a multitude of firmness options to choose from as well. While most customers like their Serta mattresses at first, there are some that had issues with durability long term, especially for the budget-friendly offerings.
The pros: iSeries and iComfort brands have something to match most customers' desired comfort levels.
The cons: Some lower priced models have issues reported about durability and initial comfort.
Price Range: $321-$3199
Final Score: 7.2 / 10
#9 Budget Brands
Wayfair also sells mattresses from a variety of budget-friendly brands that are less popular and less well-known. Some of these include Lucid, Zinus, and Symple Stuff. Many of these mattresses are available in all-foam or affordable innerspring designs. While most customers find these mattresses initially comfortable, there are some complaints about quality and durability.
The pros: Very inexpensive offerings for mattresses.
The cons: Some customers describe mattresses that break down quicker than average or have quality issues on shipment.
Price Range: $80-$599
Final Score: 7.1 / 10
Right now is possibly the very best time to buy a new mattress. With 100s of new online-only mattress brands coming into the industry over the last 5 years:
You can find competitive prices for better products if you know where to look.
Buying a mattress direct from the brand online is one of the best ways to get the most value out for your $, but not all brands are created equal. If you are willing to spend a little extra time learning about the online offerings and what fits for your body, it can literally save you $1000s of dollars and give you a better quality of life.
If you are ready to learn more about why buying a mattress online direct from the brand is better than visiting a store in person, read our 2020 Mattress Buying Guide!
...or jump right in to reading our reviews for our Top Rated Mattresses.
Very comfortable. Fast shipping no need for a box spring too!
Simply perfect Firm enough and incredibly confortable
So far after the first couple of weeks- its great!
Great mattress, came quickly and is comfortable!
It is as described and very comfortable.
Wow! Received one day shipping but there is a Wayfair Warehouse in my city. I have spine, hip and knee issues. I'm a side sleeper and on my old mattress I could not sleep for more than an hour or so without waking up in horrendous pain in my hips or knees. I was lucky to get 4 hours sleep a night total. This mattress feels like you're laying onto marsh mellows but you don't sink down into it. Then you can feel a small amount of support under that but it's just right so you don't hit pressure points. You can feel the cooling effect from the top layers as well. Definitely a temp difference when you feel it compared to surrounding air. First night of decent sleep i've had in years. This is a great value for what you are getting in my opinion. I purchased adjustable base with mattress and got it in three days so I had to wait a few days before I could sleep on it when I got it but I used the time to let it expand. No smells at all that I noticed. It comes with a 10 year warranty. Saw the mattress and base in Wayfair commercial last night while lying in it. It's currently sold out after Labor Day Sale but take a chance if you are questioning yourself purchasing this mattress. Myself and 4000+ reviewers can't be wrong....More
Love this. We gots purple for ourselves and this for our son and honestly they’re pretty similar. Def a great mattress for the $&
I loved the comfort of the mattress
Really comfy but beware! It came with big verbage on the side of the box admitting to bpa chemicals in it that can cause cancer! Also, it smelled really chemically for about 3 weeks, it stunk up the whole upstairs.
Love this mattress, so, so much!
Interesting concept for a mattress. Can't give comment yet for sleeping on it as I am waiting for my whole bedroom set to be completed. Can't wait.
great mattress, especially for the price. only criticism is it does feel more like you're sleeping on top as opposed to in. that may take some time to get used to. I would imagine the hybrid bed with coils would feel more traditional. no issues with pressure points whether you sleep on your back side or stomach. I actually did over sleep the first night I used the bed! Everytime I turn in, there's a smile on my face....More
This bed is heaven! WE had a bed that wasn't even 10-yrs old, but the springs had already started giving way. Seeing the new technology in foam mattresses had me curious to try one out. SO glad I did.
Feels like sleeping on a cloud! I can really tell the difference between Nora mattress and a spring mattress...didn’t want to get up out of bed this morning because it was so comfy! Like sleeping on a cloud for sure.
So comfortable and well made!
My husband and I upgraded from a queen size to this. I added a pillow top protector to it but it is very comfortable. It comes in a big long package but that was helpful for us because we bought it during renovations. For the price, this is a great mattress.
Love this mattress!! Super comfy...
Memory foam was the safe way to go. I’ve had the mattress for a week now, body is still adjusting to it but falling asleep is not longer a challenge. The comfort felt helps the busiest mind fall asleep like a baby.
Said it was 2 day shipping but it took way longer than that
Inflated quickly, no intense smell, perfectly firm
Wonderful mattress. We bought it for our 8 year old little girl and she swears it’s the best sleep of her life!
Very impressed with this mattress. Perfect for our guest room
Sleeps so well, my mom comes over just to sleep on it because it’s so comfortable, and I also convinced her to order two
Was skeptical at first ....But WOW it filled out and the mattress is perfect.. comfortable, forms and supports your body....don’t want to get out of bed
So far I'm loving this mattress!
For the price, it can’t be beat. I use this mattress in my guest bedroom and my guests consistently tell me how comfortable it is! It is on the firm side, so only order if you like your mattress firm (I do!)
This is a nice mattress but is not firm at all,is more like plush
This is the best mattress Ive ever owned. I cant say enough good about it. I havent slept this well in years. My shoulders dont ache anymore, I sleep uninterrupted because I cant tell when my husband gets up or back into bed. Couldnt be happier with this purchase.
I bought this for my teenage daughter. So far she really likes it. It is a little softer than I expected but totally worth the price paid. Im looking to buy a bed for myself and now I know that if Im buying a similar bed to buy an extra firm. You really just fall into the and it hugs your body.
Very nice mattress for an excellent price. It expanded to 12 inches almost immediately, and it is supportive and firm.
It's been almost a month since we got our King Tempur-Pedic Cloud Supreme Breeze. And to be honest, I'm in love. Literally obsessed. I had heard some negative things about memory foam mattresses - in particular, that they sleep hot and smell bad. Because my boyfriend and I are both hot sleepers, we decided early on to pick a mattress from the Breeze Collection. We spent a great deal of time testing the feel of each model. The Contour was way too firm, and the Flex didn't feel unique enough for the amount of money we planned on spending. So we decided on the Cloud. The Luxe was comfortable, but too soft. The Supreme, on the other hand, was soft, but offered enough support so that we were laying on the mattress, rather than in it. As far as the smell, it wasn't nearly as bad as I had expected! It didn't bother us at all. There was a slight chemical odor, like that of fresh paint, but nothing like I feared. Besides, it went away within a day or two! The only negative things about the Cloud Supreme Breeze are the weak edge support and the fact none of the Breeze covers are machine washable (just buy a mattress protector). The edge support thing doesn't affect us, but I could see it being an issue if someone were to sleep hanging off the side of the mattress. Overall, this bed has been a blessing. I don't wake up in pain anymore. I sleep throughout the night and I find myself waking up in the same position as I fell asleep in, which is an incredible feeling. And the Breeze layer keeps the bed so cool and comfortable. I wouldn't be able to relate to anyone who says memory foam mattresses sleep hot because this bed definitely doesn't! And if my boyfriend wakes up in the middle of the night, I have no clue because of the incredible motion isolation this bed offers! I would highly recommend this bed to anyone considering a memory foam mattress, or who shares his or her bed with a partner, or who sleeps hot. I couldn't ask more from a mattress.
I love my new bed! Its incredibly comfortable and soft. My husband no longer has shoulder pain when he wakes up. We're both incredibly happy with our purchase!
I was not sleeping at all. Pain in my back, legs, hips. As soon as I got up, pain went away. We decided to try the Tempur-Pedic. Now I can sleep without any pain at all. We bought an adjustable bed, that really makes it nice. I got the Breeze, my husband did not. I would definitely recommend the Tempur-Pedic bed.
Sleeping comfortably with longer interruptions for bathroom time. No wakeup with partner rollovers. Less body pain. Just feels great!
This is absolutely the best purchase I have made in over six years. Tempur-pedic is worth every penny! This is the best bed ever! Don't ever hesitate to buy this bed as it is so so worth it!
With this bed I can turn over I don't feel any hurting on my hips shoulders arms best bed ever period I also have fibromyalgia and my body does not hurt Turning over. and that's amazing
Comfortable but gets extremely hot. For about the first hour the cool gel will keep it cool, but after that it is very hot. Not recommended for hot natured person. My sister is cold natured and she loves it. I paid almost 4000. for the mattress, but I have to get rid of it.
After 6 months of sleeping on this bed I had to purchase a different mattress. It's horrible! Both my husband & I can't sleep through the night without getting up to stretch our backs. This was such a big disappointment over all. This bed was a replacement after having 3 replacements mattresses prior of the adjustable Tempurpedic mattress (due to side walls calapsing). We thought having a more expensive replacment would be better. So now this is our 4th bed in 2 yrs from this company. Such a disappointment.
After back surgery and spinal fusion, this bed was a God send. Tried all the beds and spent a ton of money. This one is the best. I even have one in my camper.
Buying a new mattress is stressful. I know I wanted the right mattress that was perfect for me and my husband. We received this bed about a week before we went on vacation. LET ME TELL YOU. This bed is unlike any other, its comfortable, it keeps you cool, I am a hot sleeper, I like to stay cool when I sleep. This was the best purchase I have ever made with buying a bed. My husband loves it, I love it our kids love it. While we went on vacation no other bed was the same, we both woke up with stiff muscles, our bodies had ached. We had stayed at a Ritz Carlton in L.A okay the beds are nice but we could not wait to go back home to get in our bed. It perfectly contours to your body, you feel rested, you don't feel your significant other getting out of bed, you sleep more deeply. You will not regret getting this bed. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND YOU BUY THIS BED NOW! !
Keep away from this product. Both my husband and I have been sound sleepers, but it has been impossible to get a good night's sleep since we got this mattress.
My wife and I have spent a ton of money on different mattresses for the last 8 years. I would like it, and she couldn't sleep. Then she would like the next one and I couldn't sleep. We were hesitant 8 years ago to try Tempur-Pedic because we heard they were hot to sleep on. Then they came out with the cooling techniques, so we bit the bullet once again and bought the Tenpur-Cloud Supreme Breeze. FINALLY...we are both able to sleep soundly and comfortably through the night with no aches and pains in the morning! Amazing! So glad we made this purchase!
We had an unusual problem with our mattress within a year of purchasing it and Tempur-pedic gave us a new one for an even exchange. It was a bit of a hassle to get the paperwork to the Warranty Dept. but once it was submitted the replacement was on order and arrived in a timely fashion. Thank you Tempur-Pedic.
Very comfortable bed have no more pain in hips or shoulders anymore. Highly recommend this bed.
This bed is amazing. It's not to firm and not to soft. It's cooler temp than other memory foam mattresses. I have had sciatica and tension headaches for years now but haven't had ANY of those symptoms since I got this bed a year ago. I never noticed any strange smells but I did buy one that had been out of the factory wrap for a discount. It's my understanding these mattresses need to air out when they are taken out of wrap for the first time. Also good to know, you MUST break in the mattress by pushing out the air bubbles. The salesperson showed me to walk on my knees slowly over entire mattress. I did this once a day and notice the full benefits of comfort after two weeks of doing that. The shape has held for the last year and has no dents. I sleep alone right in the middle with my 80lb dog. I'm 155lbs. So that much weight every night in exact same spot and no dents whatsoever. I will never buy another brand of mattress again. I will be purchasing one for my rv in the future.
It is completely different feel from our old "pillow top" mattress. Much more firm. My husband liked it from the beginning. I am still getting used to the dense firmness.
Until I get my Temp. Ped. 'official' cover, I'm using a reg mattress cover. So I'm hoping the true 'wonder' will come thru once I put that on because right now I'm bothered by some pressure points. Another thing, this about the adjustable base, ...When the foot goes up the top sheet comes untucked (OMG -- HORRORS, right? !! ) But I was thinking TP could devise something like a pouch around the foot of the mattress to tuck a flat sheet into to keep it from untucking. Just a thought from an inventor. We'll see....
I used to think that "a bed was a bed"....didn't really matter what kind it was.....until....I had 2 surgeries .....and was having such a hard/painful time sleeping....woke up many times during the night....finally I decided to try the Tempur-cloud.....wow....so much better.....the pain is so much better now....I can sleep long periods of time ....and get much better rest......the inner-spring mattress we had was awful.....I love the comfort/softness that the Tempur-cloud gives us......firm yet soft....giving support without the pressure.....allows 2 people to move about without waking each other up.....we bought the adjustable bed....and I can now read in bed....which I have not been able to do since my accident over 10 yrs. ago....very pleased with the purchase...
Fall asleep so fast and stay asleep, what a pleasure.
Our joint pains have greatly reduced, and we are sleeping longer without the need to visit the bathroom
I’m a loyal Naturepedic mattress customer because of their strict organic/non-toxic standards and the superior quality of their fabrics and craftsmanship. I’m never disappointed. I started my son on their organic crib mattress which is great. He’s 4 years old now and we’ve moved on to the twin size. There are no toxic flame retardants in this mattress and I don’t have to worry about any memory foam off-gassing. There was a slight smell the first few days but has since disappeared. The springs are firm, yet comfortable. If you’re looking for a non-toxic mattress for yourself, baby and/or child I really can’t think of another company that would make a safer mattress than Naturepedic
Was a bit worried with the "firm" description, but the softness is more of a medium to medium-firm, I'd say. Very heavy compared to a standard full mattress, which made it a little tough to lift up onto a loft. Was surprised at how small the box was when we received it, but it unrolled perfectly when we opened it. The mattress is exactly what we were looking for!...More
This mattress is great! I had been looking for a new mattress for my daughter. She says it is, the most comfortable bed ever! It came rolled up in a package, was very easy to unpackage,and was full size immediately. It also came with a letter opener to cut off the plastic. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a firm, comfortable long term mattress
I love the way mattresses are delivered in this day and age. They come rolled up in a box. The unboxing is the best part! Not only is this mattress comfortable and soft, it’s a mattress you can feel safe having your child sleep on every night. It’s made of organic cotton. There was no smell when the mattress was unboxed. Most mattresses have a potent chemical smell. Happy with this item!!...More
The Verse innerspring mattress from Naturepedic comes rolled up in a box, which was a surprise but convenient. I let it sit for several days after unrolling it before using it and you never would have known it arrived vaccum sealed and rolled. No off gassing, high quality cover, and the firmer mattress provides good support and comfort for my growing gradeschool-aged child
Best mattress out there for kids!
I love a soft, plush mattress, but this one was way too soft, almost flimsy. It reminded me of an air mattress or waterbed. I could feel every movement my partner made. Exchanged for a medium
My husband and I sold all of our furniture and moved to another state. For the first two months we slept on an air mattress and after researching all the different beds, we decided on this one. Oh. My. God. This bed is amazing. It’s like sleeping on a cloud. It’s so comfortable. I sleep in a lot of different positions and every one of them feels so good on this bed. You will not regret this purchase
Love love love my new mattress this has been the best I have gotten in a long time.
Haven’t slept on it yet but it looks great
Really hard mattress. I think I got the wrong one. Not soft or comfortable at all
Quality of this mattress is outstanding. Very comfortable. So happy with this choice.
Absolutely gorgeous. Very well designed and constructed.
What I expected...great buy...makes going to bed a vacation
Set up when delivered was nice. The mattress is very thick and plush just like we wanted.
So comfortable and you can hardly feel the person next to you ❤️
Stinky for days, but nice and firm. Hoped for a little more thickness, but it will do the trick!
Comfy! Works perfect on my day bed
Very satisfied. Didn't have any problem at all. It did what is said it would. Very comfortable mattress I've ever.
I am very pleased with this mattress firm but not too much. I have told friends and suggested they buy it if its a memory foam mattress they are looking for. Best price anywhereand on time delivery im very satisfied with purchase
Pretty good for the kids , they loved
Got this for my granddaughter. I was leery of the quality but was pleasantly surprised when it arrived. It has a nice soft covering and was a great find for the price. I’m very happy with this purchase.
I bought this mattress to replace the one at the trailer and was a little worried as I have not owned a Gel mattress before. As usual I was not disappointing, the reviews were spot on and I bought this on sale and it was worth every penny
It comes in a box super easy to just open over the platform bed I bought with it. Super nice firm soft memory foam. It's the best Mattress i've ever had. I just bought my second one!!
I bought the twin size for my 8 year old son's bunk bed. He was very quick to let me know how much he loves the new mattress - great buy and affordable price!
More firm than medium but more comfortable than i was expecting. I’ve been through the night and i have many joint problems.
Perfect for bunk beds
This mattress is exactly what we expected. More comfortable than one would think for the price. These went in the kids rooms, and they love them!
Delivery was easy and the mattrest is comfortable.
Not to firm just right and a good buy
This bed is so comfy. I feel as if am being cuddled in my sleep. Best sleep Ive had in years. Now my daughter wants one.
Very small & uncomfortable
Very comfortable and great value for its price!
Awesome bed and an even better price. Bought for a rental property and get nothing but compliments.
Very comfortable. I have been having a great nights of sleep . Very professional customer service
The mattress isn't as I expected. Its soft but not plush like I was expecting. Its an ok mattress. Another thing i didn't really like was that, when you sit on top of it or on the edges, it dips down. Even when you laying on it, it goes down a bit. Makes it uncomfortable to sleep on it. Its not bad, just could use some improvement. Pros: fast delivery and the customer service is really nice and kind
really comfortable sleeps well
I bought this and another mattress to fit a bunk bed for my sons room. This one goes on the bottom where he likes to sleep (maybe because this mattress is more comfortable I’m not sure) this is a pretty decent mattress and my sons not even 4 yet so while I prefer a softer mattress this is really nice and comfortable but firm for his rapidly growing little body. I think it’s great quality and there was no funny smell when it was opened which is really comforting (no bad chemical odor). My son loves his bed and mattress and it’s comfortable enough I don’t mind lying with him for a bit on occasion
Not happy with the quality its all springs, no support my husband probably wont like this at all, we have a serta I thought was the same bed but its totally different
Fast Shipping. Great Product for a low price. Euro Top on a 10.5" hybrid worth 5 star
Comfortable and firm enough!
It is comfortably firm and the pillow top adds a little more comfort. I wish the pillow top was a bit more plush, but it is not a big concern.
It's a comfy mattress at first, but overtime (I bought it in early May) it starts to sink in in the middle. My teen isn't even that heavy (only 100 pounds), and I was surprised that this was happening so quickly, especially to a Serta mattress.
This mattress felt better than my S...a. I would highly recommend it. The mattress is soft with some firmness.
WOW! A great mattress at a great price The best part was free delivery to my bedroom (upstairs) was included as was removal of the old mattress. Very excited to have a great night's sleep!
I purchased two of these for bottom bunk and trundle, very comfortable
This mattress was going on a murphy bed, it's slim and yet is quite comfortable. Perfect for this purpose and comfortable enough.