Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
Spring mattresses are the most traditional mattress design available with the added benefits of increased support and temperature regulating air flow vs. foam mattresses. Recent mattress designs also include pocketed coil upgrades, which independently react to the body's curves for less pressure points and less partner disturbance. But, not all spring mattresses get good ratings, with some models suffering from sagging and durability issues. We've analyzed hundreds of mattress designs and customer data across the web to bring the top rated list.
+2.2x back support
+2.1x better qualityListed top rated mattresses vs. average comparable mattresses
Spring mattresses, commonly known as innerspring or hybrid mattresses, have metal coils in their build and with a legacy from the 1800s, are still some of the most popular and comfortable mattreses on the market today. Spring mattresses have evolved a lot over the last hundred years with layers of memory foam, latex, or pillow top making for a comfortable sleeping surface. Additionally, the innovation of individually wrapped pocket coils means that spring mattresses have less motion transfer and higher comfort than ever before.
Spring mattresses have commonly been found in brick and mortar retailers, but over the past five years, there has been an influx of new mattress brands that offer direct-to-consumer options. These innovative newcomers offer lower prices and oftentimes more value than mattresses found in store that have big advertising and commission structures baked into the price. That's one of the reasons why online retailers are rated so much higher for savvy consumers. Additionally, many of these online brands provide generous trial and return policies.
The best spring mattresses offer better support because of the structural advantages of metal coils. Lower quality coils can sag faster so look for brands that take their coils seriously. Mattresses like the Brooklyn Bedding mattresses provide different firmness options for each sleeper, while DreamCloud and Bear offer extra pressure relieving layers in their higher end Premier and Elite offerings.
Coils breathe because of the air between and inside of them and that means better cooling. Brands like Bear and Saatva add layers of cooling on the surface layers as well.
No Motion Transfer
With independently wrapped coils, beds like Dreamcloud don't transfer motion and that is a big plus if you are a light sleeper with a tossing and turning partner.
DreamCloud is one of the most exciting brands with 3 of the best rated hybrid mattresses available. The DreamCloud offers the highest value of any hybrid mattress, featuring ultimate support, balanced pressure relief, and a cashmere blend top. The DreamCloud Premier is a fluffy dream that doesn't sacrifice support, great for all-around sleepers. Their DreamCloud Premier Rest adds a pillow top with a 16'' profile for the pinnacle of sumptuous, plush comfort. Customers report deeper sleep with these mattresses and with 'Buy Now and Pay Later' financing through Affirm and a 365 night trial, this is one of the best luxury bargains anywhere.
Brooklyn Bedding is a quality-focused mattress maker that produces a variety of mattresses with different firmness options. Manufacturing all of their mattresses in their own Arizona based factory, Brooklyn Bedding is able to pass on competitive prices and value to their customers. Also, read about their specialty brands: ultra-firm Plank Mattress, plus-size friendly Titan Mattress, latex Bloom Mattress, eco-friendly Ecosleep, and cooling Propel Sleep.
Helix is one of the most innovative companies in the mattress-in-a-box movement. As a leader during the industry disruption in the late 2010s, they were one of the first to offer customized mattresses with tailored firmnesses based on body type. Over the years, they developed 6 comfort designs to choose from (and thicker, Luxe versions). On top of that, their recent merger with Brooklyn Bedding means their mattresses are now made in Arizona. Whether you want to select for yourself or use their sleep quiz, Helix really puts a focus on delivering a quality mattress for every type of sleeper.
Saatva has innovated over time with their mattresses. Their original Saatva Classic mattress is one of the best mattresses online for those looking for a traditional innerspring mattress feel. With an edge on quality, Saatva invested in better coil technology in their Classic, and generous layers in their memory foam Loom and Leaf and all-latex Zenhaven mattresses. Over the years, they have innovated further, with their Saatva Latex Hybrid, the Solaire number bed, Saatva HD for larger sleepers, and their newest Modern Foam mattress.
My Green Mattress was founded with the mission to create an all-natural mattress that wouldn't harm those that are sensitive to off-gassing or other forms of toxicity in and around mattresses. From their family-owned factory, they offer a variety of Dunlop latex and pocket coil mattresses for both adults and children that are Greenguard, GOLS, and GOTS certified, which are some of the highest organic and safe certifications out there. Their mattresses get high marks from most customers and should be on your shortlist if you are looking at eco-friendly and all-natural options.
Allswell is a mattress brand that launched in 2018 to take on the direct-to-consumer mattress industry and introduce some new innovations. They offer five mattresses: the Allswell, Allswell Luxe, the plush Allswell Supreme, the firm Allswell Brick, and the luxury Allswell Cool. Each mattress features the adaptive and supportive benefit of pocketed coils with layers of foam above for pressure relief. For those on a hunt for a bargain, Allswell's mattresses are definitely a brand to consider.
Founded in 2011, Nest Bedding is an exciting addition to the mattress space. Their mattresses are manufactured in the US and include a high-end hybrid mattress, organic and natural latex and hybrid mattresses, a flippable mattress and more. With competitive price points compared to name-brand mattresses and a tradition of innovating based on customer feedback, there's a lot to love about Nest Bedding.
Dreamfoam Bedding is a lower cost brand by Brooklyn Bedding. These economy mattresses offer competitive options for the budget conscious shopper, while still having a good selection of choices featuring hypoallergenic latex, foam, and coil. Because of the lower prices, there are lower quality materials used in the mattresses, which isn't ideal for all sleepers, but for those that are looking for a temporary solution or a guest room mattress, these might work just fine.
Big Fig is the premier mattress for those with a 'bigger figure.' They make a super durable and supportive mattress that is specifically designed to support plus-sized sleepers. With capacity to withstand distributed weights of up to 1100lbs and a 20 year warranty, these sturdy mattresses are perfect for those that have suffered from a lack of support, hot sagging beds, or are looking for a firm mattress.
Brentwood Home offers mid-price hybrid mattresses with a sustainable mission, using all-natural and eco-friendly materials including recycled materials and plant-based BioFoam®. They have both all-foam mattresses, latex hybrids, and foam hybrids with layers of pocket coils. Most of their mattresses are GREENGUARD Gold certified as well, which is one of the most stringent third-party emissions certifications to get. With four different mattresses at a reasonable price for the materials, it is easy to see why customers are excited about these mattresses.