Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
My Green Mattress was founded with the mission to create an all-natural mattress that wouldn't harm those that are sensitive to off-gassing or other forms of toxicity in and around mattresses. They offer a variety of Dunlop latex and pocket coil mattresses for both adults and children that are Greenguard and GOTS certified, which are some of the highest organic and safe certifications out there. Their mattresses get high marks from most customers and should be on your short list if you are looking at eco-friendly and all-natural options.
Shifman is a handmade luxury mattress brand that has been around since the last 1800s and has a legacy of elegant design and is found in mattress retailers and at Bloomingdales. Their mattresses are very high priced, usually well over $5,000 to start. Though they are a status symbol for some and boast hand craftsmanship, there are those that find that they provide a bad value for the materials used.
Based on our aggregated reviews and our scoring method, we recommend My Green Mattress in this match up!
See Our Full Review of My Green Mattress
My Green Mattress: 9.3/10
My Green Mattress: 9.3/10
My Green Mattress: 9.4/10
No Back Pain:
My Green Mattress: 9.2/10
My Green Mattress: $649-$1594
My Green Mattress:
Get 15% Off - Code MEMORIAL15
Get Yours Now
Having great customer satisfaction is essential to both mattress companies and mattress shoppers. Customers give this brand great ratings over most competitors, which should make you feel good in learning more about their specifics. Read on to discover if one of these will work for you!
These mattresses are good in terms of their support. Reviewers describe their hips and shoulders being cradled and their spine being aligned.
These mattresses also offer suitable edge support, which is how a mattress does keeping its firmness from its core to along its sides. For folks that like to dangle their feet over the edge of their mattress, these mattresses should do a good job holding you up without sagging or contouring too much.
Bowling Ball & Density Tests
A bowling ball is good at providing an indication of firmness, and it is also helpful in how the dip it creates changes throughout the mattress. In this way, it can show if there is an even or uneven surface. Based on these factors, these mattresses do a good job in their even support.
Having a mattress that lasts a long time can means thousands of dollars in your pocket. This is a great reason for customers to find a mattress that lasts. That said, not all brands care about the same thing. Even with that, there are still some great products and brands out there. These mattresses are given high marks when it comes to durability. Unless you are of a heavy build and use the mattress more than average, these mattresses should perform for you for 7 - 12 years.
Get an Instant Discount for My Green Mattress: Get 15% Off - Code MEMORIAL15
Some customers were very happy with their new mattress, but others reported problems. Even though there are those that like these mattresses, overall they have lower customer satisfaction than average. Read on below for more information from customers if you are interested in buying.
Some reviewers feel good amounts of support in these mattresses, but some others have been dissatisfied. For those that already have aches and pains, do some added reading to make sure the mattress you buy fits you.
Reviewers have mixed concerns about edge support. Some feel positive about the mattress supportiveness across the surface, but others had problems with sags on the side.
We all want a mattress that is going to last over a decade, and when we instead buy a mattress that causes us discomfort after only a year, we feel cheated. However, finding lasting comfort nowadays is a real challenge. With more products in the industry than ever and rife competition, companies are sacrificing quality to find profits. With these mattresses, some reviewers had problems with longevity Durability issues don't happen to everyone, but make sure to read more about the warranty and the return policies.
I cannot rave about this mattress enough -- very comfortable, non-toxic materials I can feel good about (and I am very picky about everything I buy in terms of toxicity), and what a total STEAL! I had been searching for mattresses for ages, and I could not find anything I wanted for a price I could afford until I came across this one. No off-gassing, but there is a very faint, not-at-all-unpleasant, earthy smell to it. And it was delivered very fast, way before the promised time frame. Lastly, the mattress was not nearly as uncomfortably hard/firm as some of the reviews indicated. I actually wish I had not bought the expensive latex topper I already purchased elsewhere, because it really doesn't even need it. I was a little nervous about buying a mattress online, but I am SO happy with this purchase.View More Reviews
My wife is a Naturopathic Doctor and understands the importance of a natural mattress and insisted we buy one for my daughter when we moved her out of her crib. I was hesitant since these are so expensive, but she explained that sleeping on a mattress that is not natural means that her face is pressed up against chemicals and toxic off-gassing for an entire night. This was a huge concern so we searched high and low for a high quality natural mattress that would also provide her with a good night's sleep. We went to a local store that specialized in organic mattresses and could not find anything that felt good (they felt flimsy) and they were all so expensive. I decided to search online to see if I could find something and luckily I found the Echo Mattress.
We purchased the single sided Echo Mattress for my little girl and we absolutely LOVE it. It is super clean, no smells at all, and very comfortable. It came packaged rolled up and was super easy to bring upstairs and unroll onto her bed.
Now when I read my little girl bedtime stories I end up staying in bed with her a bit longer than I need to so I can enjoy her comfortable bed. I was actually enjoying my little girl's mattress better than my own so we decided to buy a King Size double sided version of this mattress for my own bed.
This is an incredible bed an a wonderful price and the customer service in this place is amazing too!
When I started waking up with back pain on my 8 year old Beautyrest mattress, I knew it was time to get a replacement. I wanted a 'natural' mattress that was free of flame-retardants and off-gassing chemicals, but most of them were way out of my price range. I found this one on Amazon and read all the reviews. Something to note: at the time of this writing, there are currently 18 reviews with an average 4 1/2 star rating. However, half of those reviewers specifically say that they purchased this mattress for a young child so they are not reviewing it from an adult's comfort perspective. I'm going to tell you right now, this mattress is firm. Very firm. Another reviewer likened it to sleeping on a bed of rocks, which is not far off. I would say it's more like sleeping on a carpeted floor. When I first started sleeping on it, I was very disappointed--it was so uncomfortable. I should add that I have a 2 inch latex topper AND a featherbed on top of it, and it's still ridiculously firm. However, after sleeping on it for seven weeks, I have gotten used to it. I am no longer waking up with back pain and I'm not breathing in toxic chemicals. Taking into consideration price, convenience (free ship/rolled up), and natural components, I would say that I am happy with the purchase. Just know that you're going to have to put some sort of topper on this mattress--I can't imagine any adult being able to sleep on this with no cushion.
The mattress arrived quickly and in good condition. We did not have any problem with the firmness, and thought it was comfortable support. My problem was with the mattress fibers/ stuffing. We let it air out for a week before putting in on the bed. Although my spouse did not notice any smell, the mattress did give me a stuffy nose every time I laid in it for about a month, even after changing out the mattress pad and sheets. This finally went away after a few weeks and I am able to enjoy the mattress now.
We were looking for a healthy alternative to our other mattress that wouldn't break the bank and would be better on our backs. We had looked at other organic mattress that were 6 times this cost so when I found this one I was estatic. This mattress has far exceeded our expectations. It is so comfortable and we don't wake up in the morning with terrible neck and back pain. Some people have complained about how hard it is, however we never experienced that. I do enjoy sleeping on the ground from time to time as it helps my back feel better so I am used to firm sleeping spaces. At first, when you open it and unroll it or does have a strong wool smell but it's nothing obnoxious and it does go away in a couple days. We have been sleeping on this mattress now for a couple months and have felt the improvement and I love knowing there's no off gassing and I sleep easier. I would highly recommend this product for anyone looking for a more budget friendly organic mattress!
I really, really wanted to like this mattress. We are very careful with the products we buy, to make sure everything is healthy and get the best for ourselves and our kids. I got this mattress in King for myself and husband, and 2 Twins for my kids. I knew it was going to be firm, but damn! It's just not comfortable. I wanted to like it, I really did- tried everything, spent more money on toppers than I ever imagined I would. I got a very fluffy lofty topper, it didn't help. I got a wool topper, still nothing. I had a firm before, but this mattress is TOO firm, I sleep on my side and have curves, it just puts pressure on my joints. Now I'm stuck and unhappy. The kids are light weight, and I got them toppers too for added comfort, but due to how they sleep- it seems to be ok for them. As for me, I'm wishing we didn't get rid of our memory foam mattress which was a lot more comfortable. We only got rid of it because we wanted to clear the house of toxins. I really, really miss that mattress. Can't afford another topper to try, or a new mattress at this time.
too firm for our taste
Like it but cant get rid of smell for month. Waiting for summer to put it on a direct sun again
What can I say, I LOVE this mattress ! It's firm without being hard.
AMAZING. This mattress came in a roll and so was really easy to maneuver onto the bed and then cut open. It is soo comfortable our daughter loves it.
I did not realize when I purchased this mattress that it is only 'one sided' but unfortunately it is and it is extremely hard. I simply would not purchase another one like this.
I don't write reviews, but we bought this mattress for our daughter and she has slept so soundly on it! Knowing what we do about off gassing and what conventional mattresses do to our bodies, we knew we had to go with this company and ultimately this mattress! Thanks again for your stellar product!
I was a little concerned about all of the reports of the smell of the mattress. When we unpacked it I didn't smell anything but when I put my nose right against the mattress and inhaled I could smell a very tiny smell that my son said reminded him of Play doh. I think it's actually the smell of the plastic that the mattress came in. If I had not been looking for the smell I would not have noticed anything at all.
This was just delivered today so I will update later. The box was quite beat up, but the mattress inside was clean (wrapped in plastic). Upon opening and unrolling there was no chemical smell: one person said 'it smells like granola' and another person said 'it smells healthy'. Three adults (of very different sizes and weights) each lay down on it (separately lol) and each found it comfortable. It is medium firmness, not hard.
most comfortable bed in our house. my father in law now kicks my son out of his bed when he visits
This is the most comfortable mattress I remember ever sleeping on. I was sure after reading previous reviews that I would need to purchase a topper to make it more comfortable, but I love it just the way it is. I sleep better than I have in years.
My spouse and I love this mattress. We've had it for about 5 months now and sleep very well on it. It's not too firm but firm enough that it won't give you back problems. It did smell a bit like wool or barn when we first got it but too the mattress' defense, I was in my first trimester of pregnancy so everything smelled to me. I aired it out in the sun for two days as the company advised and it really did help. I feel really good knowing that I sleep on a healthy mattress. I plan on buying another one.
We were looking for an organic mattress, and this one was an excellent price. That being the case, I was not expecting to find such high quality! I am very happy with this mattress! It is very firm, which I like because it has really helped my children's back issues to be sleeping on a firm mattress, yet it is still comfortable. It seems sturdy, well-made, and I have high hopes it will hold up well as my children grow up. It had no odors other than the cardboard and exterior packaging, arrived quickly and was packed all rolled-up- so it was very compact and relatively easy to transport, considering it is a mattress! I was so pleased with the purchase of the first mattress for my son that we have purchased a second for my littlest, who sleeps much better now that she is on this mattress, interestingly enough. I highly recommend this mattress and will be purchasing a third mattress after the baby on the way is big enough for a bed. Many thanks to the company for offering a quality product that is free from chemicals, well-made, and very reasonably priced.
We purchased two of these mattresses in the twin size for our four year olds. They are not super comfortable but our children seem to like them. I probably wouldn't buy them again but time will tell how well they hold up.
Matress comes rolled up and pops out like a roll of biscuits !!! Places a matress topper on it and it is money !!! Very happy with the purchase
Love it. I bought another after the first one came in, very comfortable!
This mattress is better than I expected!
t smells gross, with a really strong chemical smell that comes through the bedding even six months later. I am worried about having my child sleep on it and am considering throwing it out. I don't know what the smell is but it can't be anything good. I should have known that the price was too good to be true.
I needed a mattress that wouldn't make me swell up from all the chemicals on it. So many were expensive or didn't look very comfortable. I eventually took my chances on this one. I was concerned about the mention of smell because I am very sensitive to smells. I even called the company to ask if they could air the mattress out for a few days for me. I wasn't patient enough to wait the first time for them to answer because I needed a mattress soon but an unfortunate event turned into a fortunate result. When the bed arrived, FedEx had an accident with the package and the bed was no longer sealed inside the packaging. I called the company and sent them pictures. I called FedEx and they picked up the mattress. The mattress company remembered me and before getting the mattress back, they started airing a mattress out for the 3 days that other reviews mentioned. They sent the mattress to me before even getting the mattress back. BTW, the smell reminds me of Cheerios in case you wonder what it smells like. This mattress was just made right before it was sent to me so it is very understandable I could still smell a little of the materials. I have had it for less than a month and I sleep well. I don't wake up swollen. I am so happy about that. I have arthritis and I wake up stiff most of the time with the old mattress. I barely ever have problems with this new mattress. I got organic sheets too. The bed is firm, very firm. I like soft beds but the firmness doesn't bother me at all. The bed is wool and cotton. There isn't foam so there isn't much to make it fluffy but I figured if I had a problem, I would get a mattress topper. I don't need one though. I am quite comfy in this bed. This is a great mattress with great employees. I would highly recommend buying one.
I bought my first Shifman Mattress in Bloomdales in 2001. It lasted me over ten years and was only tossed out due to the impossibility of getting such a heavy, well-made mattress down my third floor tenement stairs. I switched brands to my regret and have never gotten the good night's sleep I had with my Shifman. I can't even turn the mattress over because it is a one-sided mattress, something I was unaware of. When this one bites the dust, I'm returning to Shifman. It is a costly product and worth every cent.View More Reviews
I am extremely disappointed with the performance of our Shifman mattress but even more disappointed with their customer service. We purchased a king pillow top mattress 20 months ago. Within a few months, large depressions began to form on each side of the bed. I called the store and was told to turn it more frequently than the once per month recommended by the manufacturer. I followed instructions and the depressions worsened. It felt as if we were sleeping in a trough with hills on either side! I contacted Shifman and received no response. I then contacted the store where we purchased the bed. They sent out a representative as well as the Shifman rep. The Shifman rep told us this was normal and we should turn the bed 90 degrees and sleep on the short axis for a month or so until the middle of the bed compresses. He never touched the bed or took any measurements to judge the depth of the depressions. Bottom line.....they will do nothing to correct the situation. Shifman has a 10 year non-prorated warranty but, clearly, they don't stand by their product. My only hope, at this point, is that the furniture store has a higher ethical standard and will make this right. Lesson learned- price is not a predictor of quality.
$4,500 for a queen size mattress and foundation and a back ache every morning! When I called their customer service, the response was (1) it was my fault because the mattress had not gotten used to me yet (after five months?) and (2) what do you want us to do about it? Then, she hung up. A second call was even worse. Someone who said she was Eileen screamed when I protested about the first call and said 'I can put you on hold' before hanging up. The crudest, rudest people I have ever encountered in business. Needless to say, their creation is out of my house, and none will ever return.
A good nights sleep is of utmost importance! I've bought Shifman mattresses in the past and although they are bit pricey, they are top quality, comfortable and well worth the cost...you get what you pay for. I would highly recommend Shifman Mattresses!!!!
We have been had 5 different beds in 16 years. This is the first bed that is so comfortable and supportive that we are getting the best sleep we ever had.
I'm awake bc a "fell in a slope" in my 4 month mattress. Stickley stands by there low quality product. Maybe Shifman Mattresses does too....
Wow Shifman Mattresses Your refusal to uphold the warranty of your product is quite disappointing. For a product that is so expensive and allegedly so high quality I would expect more from the manufacturer!
Had my first night's sleep on my new Shifman.. It was incredible! Thanks to the amazing artisans!
I was tired of low quality mattresses and wanted a mattress that could be turned. Research led me to Shifman. The problem is it is too heavy to turnover. Even when my son helps me it is too heavy. Whats the point of having a two sided mattress if its not realistic to turn it. Big grooves develope even when you rotate it. I gave 3 stars because its made relatively well but for the money spent I'll just get a regular new mattress every 5 years.