Mattress Topper Reviews

The Best Mattress Toppers

Details & Overview

Mattress toppers are a great alternative to buying a new mattress and can make your current mattress feel more comfortable than ever. With options focused on cooling, contour, or support, we've selected the most popular mattress toppers for review and some newer names that offer great products or unique offerings. With these reviews and some of the best coupons and deals, you'll be able to learn more about which bean bag chairs will work for you and which ones you may want to avoid. To rate these mattress toppers, we've used 10,000s of customer reviews and sentiment on the net. We hope that with our reviews and breakdown of the current offerings, you'll find the perfect mattress topper for your bed!

Our Reviewed Mattress Toppers

Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.

Toggle A-Z

Toggle High-Low

$100 Off Mattress Toppers
Read Reviews

Plushbeds

Overall: 9.6 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.6/10
Price: $289-$849

5% Off Sitewide - Code NEST5
Read Reviews

Nest Bedding

Overall: 9.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.4/10
Price: $159-$299

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Avocado

Overall: 9.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.5/10
Price: $299-$449

Free Gift w/ Topper - $108 Value
Read Reviews

Tempur-pedic

Overall: 9.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.5/10
Price: $299-$449

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Saatva

Overall: 9.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.3/10
Price: $135-$395

$40 Off Mattress Toppers
Read Reviews

Layla

Overall: 9.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.2/10
Price: $199-$399

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Costco

Overall: 8.6 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.5/10
Price: $49-$139

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Ikea

Overall: 8.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.4/10
Price: $89-$349

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Lucid

Overall: 8.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.6/10
Price: $39-$240

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Therapedic

Overall: 8.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $49-$399

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Kohl's

Overall: 8.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.3/10
Price: $29-$449

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Target

Overall: 8.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $11-$349

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Sleep Innovations

Overall: 8.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $119-$199

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Walmart

Overall: 8.2 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.3/10
Price: $11-$169

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Serta

Overall: 8.2 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.1/10
Price: $32-$78

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

My Pillow

Overall: 7.9 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 7.8/10
Price: $174-$297

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Avocado

Overall: 9.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.5/10
Price: $299-$449

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Costco

Overall: 8.6 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.5/10
Price: $49-$139

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Ikea

Overall: 8.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.4/10
Price: $89-$349

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Kohl's

Overall: 8.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.3/10
Price: $29-$449

$40 Off Mattress Toppers
Read Reviews

Layla

Overall: 9.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.2/10
Price: $199-$399

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Lucid

Overall: 8.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.6/10
Price: $39-$240

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

My Pillow

Overall: 7.9 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 7.8/10
Price: $174-$297

5% Off Sitewide - Code NEST5
Read Reviews

Nest Bedding

Overall: 9.5 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.4/10
Price: $159-$299

$100 Off Mattress Toppers
Read Reviews

Plushbeds

Overall: 9.6 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.6/10
Price: $289-$849

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Saatva

Overall: 9.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.3/10
Price: $135-$395

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Serta

Overall: 8.2 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.1/10
Price: $32-$78

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Sleep Innovations

Overall: 8.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $119-$199

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Target

Overall: 8.3 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $11-$349

Free Gift w/ Topper - $108 Value
Read Reviews

Tempur-pedic

Overall: 9.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 9.5/10
Price: $299-$449

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Therapedic

Overall: 8.4 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.2/10
Price: $49-$399

Get Your's Now
Read Reviews

Walmart

Overall: 8.2 /10
Customer Satisfaction: 8.3/10
Price: $11-$169

How to Choose The Right Mattress Topper?

Mattress toppers can be a nice addition to a mattress that is not the perfect firmness for you. In most cases a topper will provide a softer, more contouring surface. However, there are also firmer mattress toppers as well that are more responsive and promise to help with a slight softness that has developed in your mattress. In either case, the selection can be daunting and it can be difficult to tell which toppers are best.

However, fear not! Although taking the comfort options and designs into consideration together, it is simpler to break down each of the questions you need to answer so that you can select the best features for you and your partner. We'll go through the major questions to consider below to help you learn which features are the most important to you, and align the right product to your unique requirements.

What's The Difference Between a Mattress Topper & a Mattress Pad?

  • Toppers usually provide more firmness or softness.
  • Pads may help with cooling, warming, or waterproofing.
  • Toppers are generally thicker layers.
  • Pads are generally less thick, but may provide incremental comfort.

Which Product Options Are Right For You?

  • Do you need a topper to overcome an uncomfortable mattress?
  • How important is cooling? Is it the main goal of this product?
  • Do you want a pillowy surface layer or a single firmness?
  • Is it important for this product to be waterproof?
  • Do you suffer from allergies or chemical sensitivities?

Guide To Mattress Topper Materials & Comfort

Mattress toppers come in a variety of materials. Some are known to be quite soft and contouring, like memory foam. While others are firmer and more responsive, like latex. However, there are also options like natural or synthetic feather or down toppers, which may provide a softer surface at first but also need to be regularly fluffed to maintain their evenness.

In addition to firmness and support, some toppers and pads focus on cooling. Foam is known to sleep hot by itself, so it is often infused with gel or other heat diffusing material to remove the heat retaining qualities. Other materials that do well with this include Celliant®, a revolutionary material that converts heat to infrared light. For those that don't want cooling, there are also heated varieties for those cold winter nights.

With these comfort options, here are the most popular types of mattress toppers available:

What Makes The Best Mattress Topper?

Mattress toppers are much easier to make than full mattresses, which means that there are a bunch of competing products available out there. Unforunately, there are many brands that sell cheap and low quality mattress toppers. These can degrade quicker than average, have nasty off-gassing problems, and leave you with greater back pain than you began. But how can you tell a good mattress topper from a bad one?

Here are some of the most important things to look for when selecting a quality mattress topper:

Solid Customer Reviews & Customer Service

One of the main benefits of the Internet is that customers can speak their minds about the products they buy and their experience with each of the companies they buy from. The best products have happy customers and have good things to say about customer service. This is also the case with mattress toppers with happy customers describing comfortable and durable materials and easy buying experiences.

Good Return Policies

You don't plan to have to return a product, but if you have to, it is important to know that you can and that it is a seamless process. The best mattress topper companies make returns easy and even have warranties in place to protect customers from manufacturing defects.

High Quality Materials

Mattress toppers are not expensive to make unless they come with high quality foams or materials and exterior fabric. These oftentimes are worth the cost because they last longer and are more comfortable. Some of the best materials include high quality foams or latex, innovative synthetic fabrics, and all-natural fillings.

Disclaimer

Mattress shopping is an oftentimes tedious and mundane task. This site's sole purpose is to make the decision making process faster and more efficient. The reviews here are aggregated from other sources across the Internet and although we have tried only to find trustworthy reviews, the content and scores here may be subject to manipulation by agents acting on behalf of manufacturers and marketers. Like all things you read on the Internet, understand there is no better judge than yourself. When it comes to your own comfort, your own body is the only North Star. Where Slumber Search discusses medical ailments, we strive to ensure the information on this site is accurate, current and useful, however, we do not warrant the accuracy or completeness of any information related to medicine. We are not doctors -- if you have a medical condition, please consult your doctor.

The makers of Slumber Search also make affiliate commissions from some of these manufacturers to keep the site running. There is NO additional price markup for using this site or on links from this site and any commissions made by Slumber Search come out of the brand's profit margin. See how it all works here.