Mattress Categories

Mattress Brands

Extras

Get The Best October 2024 Mattress Deals!
Unlock Today's Coupons

Eclipse vs. Therapedic

Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.

Eclipse

Eclipse offers a variety of pocketed coil mattresses that feature thick layers of memory foam. Since 1905, they have innovated their mattresses and brought them to market at a competitive pricepoint versus many retail offerings. Though customers find their products mostly comfortable at first, there are some customers that reported durability issues.

Therapedic

Therapedic® manufactures a variety of innerspring, hybrid, latex, and memory foam mattresses. They focus predominantly on innerspring and hybrid mattresses. With a wide variety of mattress offerings and brand partnerships like Tommy Bahama®, shoppers can find both budget-friendly and more luxurious options in a multitude of firmness choices. Customers have good things to say overall with some complaints about durability and price value.

Based on our aggregated reviews and our scoring method, we recommend Therapedic in this match up!

See Our Full Review of Therapedic

See Our Top Mattress Choices

Mattress Score

Overall Score:
Eclipse: 7.8/10
Therapedic: 8.5/10

Customer Satisfaction:
Eclipse: 7.9/10
Therapedic: 8.7/10

Price Value:
Eclipse: 8.7/10
Therapedic: 8.7/10

No Back Pain:
Eclipse: 8.7/10
Therapedic: 8.2/10

Price:
Eclipse: $299-1999
Therapedic: $899-$2499+

Eclipse:
Get Yours Now

Therapedic:
Get Yours Now


Eclipse's Owner Satisfaction

Some customers felt very comfortable with their new mattress, but others couldn't get comfy. Despite those that are cozy, this means that these mattresses have lower than average customer satisfaction. Read on for more specifics if you are interested in buying.


Eclipse's Supportiveness

These mattresses don't fit the needs of everyone in terms of support. Though some folks like the feel of these mattresses, others have found these mattresses to disagree with their backs. If you are thinking about this mattress, make sure that it works for your body before buying.

Edge Support
Edge support is definitely a concern for those that struggle with mobility. Some folks, however, don't report it being as large of an issue for them. Overall these mattresses aren't as supportive over the long term so if edge support is important, make sure to do extra research.


Eclipse's Durability

Finding a mattress with long lasting comfort is awesome, but difficult. Sadly, sleepers don't rate these mattresses well when it comes to durability. This means that some customers may experience that their mattress lasts longer than average, while other sleepers may find their mattress falters quickly. If you are a bigger person, make sure to take a look at all of your options.

Therapedic's Owner Satisfaction

Looking over customer reviews and ratings is a strong way to figure out if a company will meet your criteria. Overall, these mattresses are regarded highly by customers, but there are some that had a negative experience. Research more below to see if one of these mattresses will work with your body type.


Therapedic's Supportiveness

Mattresses that give good support are oftentimes thought of as firm, but when we talk about support, we're describing support that cradles the body ergonomically. These mattresses are well rated at giving support to the average sleeper, but there is the occasional complaint about the feel.

Edge Support
These mattresses have good support along the edges, which what customers want who sit on the edge of the mattress or roll over towards the edge at night.

Bowling Ball & Density Tests
The bowling ball test is useful for measuring if a mattress will give a good surface to support the spine. These mattresses are above average in providing support, but you should do additional research if you have a larger or smaller than average body type.


Therapedic's Durability

Durability stems from good materials, craftsmanship, and quality control. Companies may have disagreements with sleepers if they don't invest in these attributes. Unfortunately, customers have mixed feedback on these mattresses on durability. Some report finding lasting comfort, while others complain about discomfort over the short term. Make sure to double-check the warranty and return policies before buying.

Browse Eclipse Customer Reviews

No complaints thus far
Me and the wife are sleeping well since we bought one of these. We were happy with the eco-friendly score and the low impact on the environment. It's a pretty decent bed. Not a lot of tossing and turning, but still wake up sometimes in the night. May just be me.

Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews

Not a fan
Tried to love this mattress after the salesperson told me it was going to be the best thing I ever sleep on. However, kinda dissapointed because it doesn't feel quite right for me. I am a bit heavier and am a side sleeper so it could just be that the bed doesn't fit me.

Meh
Meh is all I really have to say. Don't hate it, don't love. After seeing more reviews on things people love, I feel like I should have bought something else. But, at least I don't hate it.

Best bed ever
I'm a back sleeper and pretty light -- I definely love my bed. I put on the comfy comforter over it and it immediately welcomes me to it every time I come home from work. It is becoming a part of me and my cat loves it too!

My wife loves it
My wife conviced me to get a new bed for the holidays and so it was our big gift this year. She loves it so I'm happy. For me, it's just okay -- I don't really notice the difference between it and the old IKEA bed that we had that suited me just fine.

Love this bed
The Eclipse gel memory foam mattress is really nice on my back. I sleep through the whole night now and don't have any complaints about anything. Feeling rested.

Great but after 3 months...
Great but after 3 months it seems to have developed a sag where I sleep. It definitely seems like a defect in the foam because I haven't had this for that long. I am definitely going to see if I can work with the seller.

Starting to sag
I felt like I was sleeping on a cloud for the first few months, but now there is a noticeable dent where I sleep. I am starting to rotate the bed after only a couple months!!!

Sleeping happy
Finally sleeping good after buying this mattress. I was sleeping on an old coil mattress that hurt my back over the years and this one is finally putting me at ease. Love it!

Good night sleep
Really pleased with my new Eclipse mattress. No complaints.

Thank you for making my back worse!
If I could survive on 3 hours sleep each night, this mattress would be fine..... BUT I CAN'T!

Very Nice & Comfortable
I have purchased a Ortho Care Mattress which is very nice & comfortable.Main thing is that my father had a problem on his spinal cord after using this product he felt very well...

Value for money
great mattress.very comfortable. Really its a value for money mattress

Defective mattress
Princeton double bed mattress purchased on 08/11/2019 from My Home , Green Park , New Delhi has developed problems . Its springs are making noise while sitting or sleeping or as soon as some pressure is applied on the mattress and springs can be felt thru the foam covering. A very bad experience for a consumer given to believe he is buying the best mattress in the world. Complaint was lodged with the shopkeeper and subsequently Mr Akhtar ( 9818147219) visited on 18/12/2019 and acknowledged the problem saying there is some manufacturing defect but despite 2 weeks of lodging a complaint , no subsequent action has taken place.

Worst experience
Bought orthocare model. The mattress was good initially. But after few months it slacked. Contacted dealer and customer care but they least bothered. Will not recommend anyone to buy.

AVOID THIS OFFICE AT ALL COST
I brought this mattress for my husband because he's recovering from a stroke, and I need something that was going to be good for him. With him being in bed all day on some days. We got the ECLIPSE Platinum Firm Set 5/28/2018 and it was sagging by January of 2019 you slide off the sides. DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS EVER!!!!!:( I can reach the warranty office its crazy DON'T DO IT!!!:(

Defective at 3 months
Defective bulging on the side and there was sagging in the middle so very dissappointing . Very surprise $800 and its not good

ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE
DO NOT BUY THIS BED!!! unless you like sleeping on rocks I strongly urge you to buy any bed other then this! I’ve had this bed for about 2 weeks now and every morning since I’ve bought it I’ve awoke every morning with excruciating back pain. Feels nothing like the model that was on display. They have it Rated a 4 in softness. Should be a 9 or 10. Complete trash!!! It’s so bad I’ve resorted to sleeping on my 10 year old mattress. DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS!!! You’ve been warned

Browse Therapedic Customer Reviews

Good mattress
I love my therapedic mattress. I've had it for the past 6 months and I can't say enough good things. The only thing that I don't like is that I feel like it has fallen about an inch since I got it. I am worried that it will continue to sag.

Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews

Sleeping like a baby
I am really happy with my Therapedic mattress. It has been a good investment for my health and I've never been happier.

Sagging
Not the happiest with the mattress because it has only been two years since I bought it, but it has a deep sag in it. I am not a particularly heavy person, but I'm still experiencing sagging? I need to find my warranty.

Most comfortable bed ever
This is one of the most comfortable beds I have ever slept in my entire life! Really enjoy the Eclipse I have!

Great Mattress
Love this mattress! Not like other memory foam mattresses where you sink in. My husband always gets so hot when he's sleeping and this seems to be a lot cooler as well.

Five Stars
love this mattress pad, very comfortable

Five Stars
OMg, this is a fabulous mattress cover.

Not a fan
Did not like the feel of the Therapedic mattress. I am used to an innerspring mattress so you might like it more than I did.

Love this mattress
Everything about this mattress I love. It doesn't contour too much to me so I can get comfortable. I haven't slept this well in years!

Okay but...
Okay but the delivery was such a pain. The box was shredded and arrived late. Besides that, the bed is nice.

Really couldn’t be more happy
Really couldn’t be more happy with our Agility mattress. My wife and I genuinely look forward to going to bed each night. It’s that comfortable. I’m a side sleeper, so support for my hips and shoulders is critical. This mattress allows heavier pressure points to sink appropriately making my whole body feel cradled. Very happy with my purchase.

I was fortunate
I was fortunate enough to win an Agility mattress in a sweepstakes recently. The mattress on our bed was very old and tired, so I was very excited. I was also skeptical about getting a rolled up mattress in a box. It arrived very quickly after being notified. My husband and I hauled the box into the bedroom , and we leaned our old mattress up against the bedroom wall - just in case we wanted it back on the bed! It was very easy to set up - took no time at all. That night I slept through the night for the first time in months. I'm not a good sleeper, and am usually up several times during the night. Since sleeping on the Agility I have been able to go back to sleep if I wake up without a lot of wrestling around. My 10 year old dog, who hasn't slept with us for a few years, has now taken up residence in the middle of the bed each night, and is still there when we wake up in the morning. I guess Agility needs to look into making dog beds next! We will be taking our old mattress to the dump this weekend, and are definitely enjoying our new Agility mattress! Thank you!!

I ordered the twin bed for my 3 year old
I ordered the twin bed for my 3 year old and he has said more than once “Mama, I love my new bed!” He often refers to his bed as “cozy comfy” – and believe me, it is. Before we received our Agility mattress, my son was on a week-long nap strike. After we setup his new bed, he started napping again with no issues – and not wanting to wake up! He also falls asleep faster at night with his new bed. Just shows how important a good mattress is for all of us. Now I want one for my Master!

I was a little concerned
I was a little concerned about buying my daughter a mattress online. However, once we set-up her new Agility mattress and let it expand, a supremely comfortable mattress came to life! And once I slept on the mattress myself, I knew I’d made the right choice. It’s super comfortable!

I wasn’t sure what to expect
I wasn’t sure what to expect, but Agility truly delivered. The mattress is excellent, and I am very satisfied with how comfortable it is. I’m a back sleeper, and it has been great.

Great customer service
Great customer service. Thank you to Sales Representative Derek and Therapedic Mattress. Cheers!

The employees were very pushy
The employees were very pushy and one told us we couldn't look at certain sets of mattresses. We ended up purchasing one from the store based on price, but we will not be coming back.

I have had nothing but good things to say
I have had nothing but good things to say about them. Fast shipping and great priced mattresses.

I had the worst experience here
I had the worst experience here.. they order a bedroom set without my permission and when I went in to get my money back I was told by Paula that I would have to wait for an hour to let her boss get off a conference call.. I said I just want my money. Paula told me that she has to look out for herself and her job and I would have to wait.. Paula was extremely rude and had very poor customer service..

I can't wait
I can't wait to get into bed each night. I nestle down into the mattress and go to sleep quickly. Thanks to Agility Bed.

The Agility bed was a huge upgrade
The Agility bed was a huge upgrade from our old "memory foam" mattress. Previously, I thought I preferred a firmer mattress - so at first, the Agility bed felt almost too soft. But after a few months of great rest, I am super pleased by the balance of comfort and support - it's just right (no additional mattress topper needed). As I am almost 6mos pregnant, I can also attest that it's great for side-sleeping.

Just love it!
Just love it! Why did I wait so long to get it.

My Agility Bed is wonderful
My Agility Bed is wonderful. I don't think that I have ever slept so well. Thank you, Pam

This is my second Agility mattress
This is my second Agility mattress purchased so now each of my twin children have one! The Agility mattress was shipped right to my house and was very easy to install. My kids love these mattresses and they are so comfortable that you never want to leave them. Next will be one for my older daughter. Thank you Therapedic!

We are LOVING our Agility Mattress
We are LOVING our Agility Mattress. Previously, we had purchase a Purple Mattress hoping that it would be the answer to both my husband and I waking up achy from an older mattress that was past it's prime. We tried it for 2 months, hoping we'd adjust, but it was just too firm. I heard about the Agility Mattress on Young House Love Has a Podcast and thought that it might be worth a try. It's so much better - still supportive but offers more give for my shoulders as a side sleeper. We are planning to replace our kids mattresses with an Agility Mattress too!

I don't know why I waited so long
I don't know why I waited so long to get this mattress. My husband and I have slept so well and his back doesn't bother him anymore. Also, customer service was ah-may-zing.

Allington
Bought an allington queen size mattress for spare room thinking it would be good enough even though it only cost a little under 400. Mistake,,,, I have 23 yrs of sleeping on military provided mattresses so I'm anything but picky.... this mattress is lumpier than anything I've ever used. Im wishing I'd saved the 25 yr old mattress it replaced. I weigh 230 lbs so I know it's expecting a lot to hope for perfect but at least better than sleeping on a rock pit. And yes I did give it time... 2 months.

Agility truly delivered.
I wasn't sure what to expect, but Agility truly delivered. The mattress is excellent, and I am very satisfied with how comfortable it is. I'm a back sleeper, and it has been great.

the ease of ordering plus delivery sold me!
My son was starting to show signs of being ready to switch to a twin bed from his toddler bed. I decided to take a chance on a delivery mattress. I barely have enough time to take a shower, so the ease of ordering plus delivery sold me! The ease of assembly was even better. My son's new bed was up in no time and he has adjusted easily!

We have never slept better!
The bed could not be more comfortable. We have never slept better!

I'm ready to buy one for ourselves in our master bedroom!
We needed a new mattress for our guest bedroom & decided to give Agility a shot. Now I'm ready to buy one for ourselves in our master bedroom!

I'm never going back to another mattress
The old saying is true: You get what you pay for. I'm never going back to another mattress I found my perfect fit with Agility!

The whole Agility experience was fantastic.
The whole Agility experience was fantastic easy ordering process, quick delivery and the mattress is as comfortable as promised. My wife and I had a wonderful, restful night's sleep. Would definitely recommend purchasing your next mattress with Agility!

I've never had a better night's sleep than on my Agility mattress!
I've never had a better night's sleep than on my Agility mattress! So glad I listened to my sister's recommendation. The process was easy and the mattress arrived within a few days. Thanks, Agility!

The ease and comfort are unbeatable!
I needed the whole bed so I ordered mine with a foundation. I cannot express how easy the foundation was to put together. I did it completely by myself in less than an hour. The ease and comfort are unbeatable!

I want one for my Master!
I ordered the twin bed for my 3 year old and he has said more than once Mama, I love my new bed! He often refers to his bed as cozy comfy and believe me, it is. Before we received our Agility mattress, my son was on a week-long nap strike. After we setup his new bed, he started napping again with no issues and not wanting to wake up! He also falls asleep faster at night with his new bed. Just shows how important a good mattress is for all of us. Now I want one for my Master!

We will be taking our old mattress to the dump this weekend, and are definitely enjoying our new Agility mattress!
I was fortunate enough to win an Agility mattress in a sweepstakes recently. The mattress on our bed was very old and tired, so I was very excited. I was also skeptical about getting a rolled up mattress in a box. It arrived very quickly after being notified. My husband and I hauled the box into the bedroom , and we leaned our old mattress up against the bedroom wall - just in case we wanted it back on the bed! It was very easy to set up - took no time at all. That night I slept through the night for the first time in months. I'm not a good sleeper, and am usually up several times during the night. Since sleeping on the Agility I have been able to go back to sleep if I wake up without a lot of wrestling around. My 10 year old dog, who hasn't slept with us for a few years, has now taken up residence in the middle of the bed each night, and is still there when we wake up in the morning. I guess Agility needs to look into making dog beds next! We will be taking our old mattress to the dump this weekend, and are definitely enjoying our new Agility mattress! Thank you!!

Really couldn't be more happy with our Agility mattress.
Really couldn't be more happy with our Agility mattress. My wife and I genuinely look forward to going to bed each night. It's that comfortable. I'm a side sleeper, so support for my hips and shoulders is critical. This mattress allows heavier pressure points to sink appropriately making my whole body feel cradled. Very happy with my purchase.

My husband and I have slept so well and his back doesn't bother him anymore.
I don't know why I waited so long to get this mattress. My husband and I have slept so well and his back doesn't bother him anymore. Also, customer service was ah-may-zing.

We are LOVING our Agility Mattress.
We are LOVING our Agility Mattress. Previously, we had purchase a Purple Mattress hoping that it would be the answer to both my husband and I waking up achy from an older mattress that was past it's prime. We tried it for 2 months, hoping we'd adjust, but it was just too firm. I heard about the Agility Mattress on Young House Love Has a Podcast and thought that it might be worth a try. It's so much better - still supportive but offers more give for my shoulders as a side sleeper. We are planning to replace our kids mattresses with an Agility Mattress too!