Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
Charles P Rogers has been making bedding since 1855 with the goal of making the finest beds. They still have their location in New York City and also ship their bedding nationwide. Overall, they specialize in offering hand crafted mattresses, frames, and beds. They offer hybrid mattresses with latex and memory foam.
King Koil is a mattress brand that was founded in 1898. It started selling innerspring mattresses, but over the years has expanded to foam mattresses as well. You can find King Koil mattresses across the globe in local retailers. Some of their mattress models may be advertised under other names. Overall, they make comfortable mattresses in a variety of pricepoints, but some may find more value for the materials in other brands.
Based on our aggregated reviews and our scoring method, we recommend King Koil in this match up!
See Our Full Review of King Koil
Charles P Rogers: 8.1/10
King Koil: 8.4/10
Charles P Rogers: 8/10
King Koil: 8.5/10
Charles P Rogers: 8.1/10
King Koil: 8.2/10
No Back Pain:
Charles P Rogers: 8.1/10
King Koil: 8.5/10
Charles P Rogers: $899-$2999
King Koil: $549-$3,399
Charles P Rogers:
Get Yours Now
Get Yours Now
Finding out how sleepers really feel about a mattress is difficult business -- especially with some companies moderating reviews. These mattresses, unfortunately, aren't scored as well by customers. There are still customers that are very satisfied, but many others who are not. Make sure to read on to figure out if they will work for you.
Having a supportive mattress is a make or break for stomach and back sleepers. Also, having good support that aligns the spine is a must-have for side sleepers. These mattresses do well overall with support. However, others had problems with the support so if you have a heavy build, make sure to dig into the specifications.
Most customers like the support in the edges of these mattresses. Some, however, had some complaints about the support.
Based on the materials that are in the mattress, the average durable mattress will stay comfortable for at least 7 - 12 years. Foam mattresses are generally less durable, while coil mattresses that are high quality should last longer. That said, mattresses that don't focus on durability will start sagging much faster especially for larger customers. These mattresses get mixed emotions from sleepers. Some report lasting comfort, but others report quicker than average degrading.
There have been assorted feedback from customers on these mattresses -- both good and bad. Many sleepers report feeling comfortable with their decision and enjoy their new mattress, but there were others that complained. Learn more about this brand below!
Having a supportive mattress is essential to getting the most out of your night's sleep. These mattresses are above average in their supportiveness. This is important if you have back problems or need something that will keep the spine aligned properly. Most customers describe these mattresses as providing good support in the short term.
Edge support is the measure of supportiveness along the sides of the mattress. These mattresses offer a good amount of edge support, but there are some folks that may experience more contouring along the edge.
Bowling Ball & Density Tests
The bowling ball test is great for those that want to understand if a mattress is going to be firm or soft. It is also great for figuring out if there is supportive evenness or if there are peaks and valleys. Overall, these mattresses should work with your body and offer an even support feel.
Mattresses may not last as long as they used to. For those that are looking for mattresses that last over 15 years, these days it can be hard to find. That said, finding a long-lasting mattress can mean hundreds of dollars in your pocket. These mattresses get mixed feedback when it comes to durability. Many customers don't report problems, but others have issues with lasting comfort over a shorter than average horizon.
We recently ordered the solide bed, and it came in the mail a few days ago However, after setting up the entire frame, we realized that the platforms were missing. Consequently, we had to move the frame out of the bedroom and our old bed back in.View More Reviews
The delivery was well done, courteous, and on time. We bought the tiger mahogany Hampton king bed with white leather headboard and the PowerCore 7000. My husband and I assembled the bed. We were pleasantly surprised, every screw, washer and parts were all included. It took a few hours, the bed is well made, solid, and every part fit together perfectly. It looks beautiful. Very happy with our experience but we have not slept on the bed, waiting for the new carpet's off gassing to dissipate. No off gassing from the bed/mattress though. I spent three months researching bed construction and mattresses, including reading the Old Bed Guy blog. I concluded this was the best available for the money. My husband who was initially sceptical of buying online, sight unseen, is sold! My only issue was I wished the bed was a available in expresso without an extra $250.
kind customer service, smooth delivery and extremely happy with our choice 6 months in( st regis pulse latex)
Great mattress, great customer service at the New York site. Word on the street is that buying a mattress takes a lot of time, energy, and choices between seemingly endless mattress choices. I found this brand while researching mattresses online. I wanted something firm, and based on reviews, as well as more formal reviews by Consumer Reports, I felt like the Charles Parker 5000 was going to be the one. My partner and I went to the show room, met with a super sales guy, very 'no pressure' which I like, and tried it out. 20 minutes later, we had purchased the mattress, set up our delivery time and we're all set for sleeping in a king sized mattress. Delivery was smooth, no issues. Our first night of sleep was good,a month later, it was excellent. The mattress is firm to very firm, and it took a moment to get used to it from our older, worn in, mattress. She sleeps on her side, and I sleep on my back. Both of us get a great night rest. Both of us get up at different times; motion from one partner makes no impact to your sleep mate. We love it!
ISSUE #1: When I made the order, I received an email confirmation. However, I also received an email saying that they charged me 20%. I wasn't sure why. Maybe that's posted on their website somewhere but I didn't see it. So I emailed them to ask why and they emailed right back to let me know they hold a 20% deposit. Good to know. An explanation would be good to have somewhere, like in the email confirmation.
Other than a fairly long wait for delivery our bed was extremely well packaged and arrived with no damage at all. The delivery crew were very polite and helpful. Everything was there and putting the bed together was easy. We are very happy with the finished product.
After a conversation with a phone representative, we ordered the memory foam version of this mattress. This turned out to be a mistake for me, as the heat retention of the memory foam kept me from sleeping well, even after 45-60 days.. The underlying mattress was excellent, however. The pulse latex would have been the right choice for us. To be honest, I'd raised this issue of heat retention with the representative and wished that he'd thought to steer us to the pulse latex initially. I knew we could exchange, but I hadn't been told that there would be a $375 charge for the exchange in addition to the price difference. So this was a disappointment. But we now have the pulse latex version and it's marvelous. Both versions are great unless, like me, you are sensitive to the heat retention of the memory foam. We sleep much better with the new mattress. I highly recommend it.
Earlier this year I purchased the Fairnoble Sleigh Platform Bed - beautiful quality and craftsmanship. I shopped around a number of other local vendors to find the right mattress. I was fortunate to find the St Regis on sale at Charles P Rogers. After reading positive independent reviews, I decided to give it a try - taking a chance ordering online. I love this mattress! The quality is excellent, and it is the perfect balance of firmness with a cushion-y upper layer. I highly recommend not only these products, but also must say that my experience with the Charles P Rogers company has been completely satisfying. I would not hesitate to refer potential buyers, or to purchase again from them in the future.
I love love my st Regis , Im so happy to have purchased this mattress, I sleep fabulous, this is so comfortable,worth every penny, I also purchased an encasement so my Mattress is protected , very comfortable feels fabulous
The mattress was double wrapped when it arrived in perfect condition. We have used it a month now and are resting comfortably after sleeping on a 15 years old mattress with lumps and indentations. Excellent buy. Thank you for the free shipping!
Very pleased with the St. Regis Queen Pulse Latex Mattress. My husband recently had back surgery and this mattress works for him. I have some arthritis issues and it works for me. Very pleased with the order process and delivery. Mattress was delivered to the bedroom, unwrapped, and trash removed by the delivery team. Because we are several states away, delivery took a few weeks. The only thing that would have made it better was to get the mattress sooner!
We like this mattress very much and would readily recommend it to friends or family. It is 'firm' the way we like our mattresses. We researched mattresses online and with Consumer Reports and choose this mattress. We just ordered another mattress, a king size, for our master bedroom because of the quality of this mattress. The mattress is soundless when you shift your position in bed.
I was extremely impressed by Charles Rogers from beginning to end. I wanted to place an order and emailed with a question at a time that I knew was afterhours for their customer service department - and yet someone got back to me almost immediately to answer my question and encourage me to place my order because the New Year's sale was ending the following day. Delivery was easy, the guys brought it all the way in, unwrapped it and set it up. The mattress is good quality. As is, it was a little too hard for me - I wish that the pillowtop was just a bit more plush so you get the feeling of luxuriousness as you sink into it. But I got it closer by buying a mattress cover with an additional pillowtop. Absolute perfection? Maybe not, but darn close! Full disclosure that I am a side sleeper and am thin, so boney, hence the need for softness. All in all, I am very happy with the quality and customer service for the price.
My entire experience with Charles P. Rogers was excellent. I love the fact that they have this old school showroom. Everyone I dealt with when visiting the showroom was extremely helpful and good natured. I went with a platform bed and the St. Regis mattress. I rent my guest room out on Air BnB and it surprised me how many of the guests report to me and in reviews that this is the most comfortable mattress they've slept on. I occasionally sleep on it myself between guest visits. It's cushy yet firm. The entire experience couldn't have been better. Expect my current guest from Seattle to reach out and order the mattress soon. He loves it as well! And how cool that this company has been in business since 1855! They must be doing something right.
If you want an ultra comfortable mattress with top level construction and absolutely no toxic outgassing and odor, this is THE mattress to buy. We had some horrible experiences trying brands such as Simmons (horrible odor that didn't dissipate even over a month) and Satva (no odor but really inferior construction, uncomfortable, and they offered me a $400 refund to take down negative reviews). But, eventually we found CP Rogers. Wish that had happened sooner, but so glad that, ultimately, it did. We've been to the showroom and factory in NJ, and there's no chemical odor whatsover on the shop floor. And sleeping on the 9000 is incredible --something to look forward to at the end of the day.
The estate 9000 is a beautiful mattress and very heavy. In discussing our needs with the rep, we decided on the 9000 although it is difficult to know which mattress would ultimately be best by simply talking to someone, without laying on the bed. We have no regrets in buying the 9000 but will say that it was a bit too firm and I added a memory foam pad to soften it. We sleep well on it and have high hopes that it will last for many years as it is a quality mattress.
I had been sleeping on an old, heavy, top-of-the-line, outrageously expensive Kluft before and had enjoyed it for many years -- but all good things come to an end eventually, In 2016 I tried the top two versions of the Saatva mattress, but sent them back: they simply were not solid enough for me. Then I slept on the 2016 version of the Charles P. Rogers Powercore Estate 9000 -- a great improvement over the Saatvas, but it felt a little hard to my aging body. The new version of this bed, however,. with the "latex comfort select cassette" system as a top layer, is just perfect for me. I absolutely love it. The delivery guys they use are terrific, too. Happy end of story.
This mattress is comfy! It's not too firm and not too soft. I love it! I was a little nervous before I bought it because the price is so low. Once I went in the store and tested it out, I knew I was going to get my monies worth. Granted I've only had it for about a week now, even my boyfriend has confirmed it's super comfortale. Get it while it's on sale.View More Reviews
I bought the twin mattress and much to my dismay there was about a 4 inch gap between the mattress and my bed frame. After measuring the mattress I realized it was only 36 inches wide, not the standard of 39 inches (despite the website listing it as 39 inches wide). I finally got a hold of the manufacturer and they said that their twins are "intended" to be 38 inches wide but that each one can differ by up to two inches. So you're basically left with a mini-twin. I will be returning this.
It's pretty comfy for the price but honestly I could have gotten cheaper at another matress store, definitely shop around more. It's not very thick and the euro top seems like it will be flattened very easily I give it maybe a year before it starts losing its comfort completely
My first set of guests found this to be very comfortable. I slept in the guest room to try it out and found it very comfortable. I am very pleased with this purchase and will purchase future items.
Nice product at the right price. My child needed a mattress for a new college apartment. We saw many options and even ran into a manufacturers rep at the store who helped us with good advice. As usual, the experience was great
love this mattress very comfortable the never disappoint
Great price and such an amazing mattress. The level of comfort is undeniable. I'm very happy with this product and would recommend it in a heartbeat.
This mattress was purchased for a bedroom that is only used for guests and when child is home from college. The mattress is very comfortable and the price is perfect for this situation. We have had it about a week and my kid loves it, it's 12:20 pm now as I write this review and she is still sleeping.
Buying this mattress was an amazing investment. Such a comfortable bed to sleep on and the service and delivery was very prompt and professional.
Very happy with what I bought slept like a baby. The delivery guys came set it up fast. Very happy with the service.
My husband and I are sleeping so much better since purchasing this mattress. It's not too firm or too soft, so you get support without feeling like you're sleeping on a board.
We love our new Mattress! The comfort and quality is unbelievable and for what we paid for it...we just love it!!
I purchased two of these mattress for my boys, without them being there to try them, and they just love it. They said it's so comfortable that it just conforms to their bodies. Mind you my 15 year old is 262lbs and said the bed is like a giant blanket. So hats off for a great product at a reasonable price...
I recently stayed in a bed in a breakfast in Maine--and loved the mattress I slept on. (I've got neck and shoulder issues to the mattress is often crucial.) I found a similar King Koil mattress and Raymour and Flanigan. The price was right; the delivery was prompt. "For this relief much thanks." Happy with my purchse: feels good!
When choosing a bed we needed a firm mattress with back support for me but yet some cushioning for my husband and the King Koil Perfect Response Elite Lakeside Pillowtop was "the perfect" choice. Very pleased with our decision and we even received next day FREE delivery - very nice!
I love my new mattress -and the service that came with it.
The bed is great. It came when they said it would and the sales person was wonderful in working with our family.
Bought this for my guest bedroom and it was given an A plus By my first guest. She couldn't believe it was a firm mattress. Would highly recommend.
WE NEEDED A FIRM MATTRESS AND THIS IS PERFECT! NOT ONLY IS IT EXACTLY WHAT WE WANTED THE INSTALLATION WAS WONDERFUL. WE NEEDED SLATS FOR SUPPORT AND THE DELIVERING TECHS DID IT ALL WITH NO PROBLEM. SALES PERSON WAS WELL INFORMED AND ANSWERED ALL OF OUR QUESTIONS. FLO L
I have a California King Mattress and it is the best.... I was not sure of down sizing to a Queen Mattress, but I must say that it was the best choice I love the way my body rest and the best part is that my husband and I are know closer....
THE MATTRESS AN BOX SPRING I PURCHASED WAS JUST EXCELLENT. ITS MEETS ALL MY STANDARDS FOR COMFORT .THE SALES PEOPLE WERE JUST GREAT HELPING ME FIND THE RIGHT ONE . I HIGHLY RECOMMEND MY CHOICE.AND THE STORE LOCATION ON CROPSEY AVENUE
It's hard to get out of bed after sleeping on this very comfortable mattress. You look forward to relaxing at the end of the day. I like it very much. Keep in mind, coupled with the box spring, it is very high. Can't go wrong with this one, unless you like it extremely firm. It has the right kind of firm but soft too.
Very happy with our purchase! Bed is comfortable. Not too firm, not too soft. Great quality for a great price!
The mattress is very comfortable. It's the best sleep I've had in a long time. It is a 5 star hotel quality mattress. I'm in love. I must stress that the hubby that works at night and have Insomnia also agreed that his sleep has been much better. Thumb's up.
I absolutely love my new bed. Best experience it's comfortable for my back after I come home from work cause I work 19 hours of the day doing labor and I just needed a new way to sleep. This is one of the most comfortable beds I've ever slept in and I highly recommend it to everyone.
The store was great the product was well priced and it was a convenient purchase. Loved the salesmen [Associate name removed].
This mattress has just enough firmness topped with a pillow top that has just enough softness! The price is perfect and the customer service was out of this world. No one trying to force me to the most expensive products in the store.
I am very much enjoying my new mattress. I was afraid it might be too soft but I'm glad I went with the softer mattress over the more firm mattress. While this is soft, it is still very supportive. This mattress is great quality for a good price.
great mattress sleep like a baby love it so much it is great
Best decision i made for my son he loves his new bed. Raymour and flanigan alway have good quality furniture which last a long time. I know when i shop with them im getting good stuff.
I needed a mattress for my fathers spare bedroom so I had a place to sleep when I visited. I didn't want to spend a lot but I wanted something that was nice and comfortable. This mattress is it! I have slept great when visiting him now and the Sales associate Tom P. in Clifton Park listened to my needs and took care of everything! Thank you Tom!
very comfortable but still with support!! Very happy!!
This mattress was purchased for a guest room and has only been slept on once with a report that is was very comfortable. The salesman was very helpful and polite. The delivery team were very helpful and delivered quite timely
I really like this mattress. It's really comfortable and it feels like I'm sleeping on a cloud.
My old mattress was still in good looking shape, but had outlasted the years I needed an extra firm mattress. My new King Koil plush is so comfortable, I sleep right through the night. Both my husband and I are well pleased with this purchase.
Mattress is unbelievably comfortable. My wife and I love it so much.
So far so good! Great price for the quality. I'll write another review after about a month or so
I am so happy with my purchase. I haven't slept this well in a long time. I definitely Recommend this mattress. The salesman was very knowledgeable and he listened to my needs.
I am very happy with my king coil mattress purchase. In the past I have always bought Sealy's. It is very comfortable and I am happy with it. Also the service at the store and the delivery was very good. I am also very happy with the guarantee on the mattress.
Mattress after the first night of sleep had a indentation in it already. Was or is not as comfortable as I expected.