Bear Mattress vs. Birch Living
Slumber Search is supported by readers. Some links on Slumber Search are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Slumber Search may make a small amount of money. More info.
Bear Mattress
Bear offers 5 top-rated mattresses. Their Bear Original memory foam has won acclaim with athletes on a budget. For those looking for a pressure-relieving feel, the Star Hybrid and Pro Hybrid are great options. Sleepers looking for the responsive feel of natural latex will enjoy the Bear Natural hybrid mattress. Lastly, their Elite Hybrid, features both cooling foams and zoned support to provide sleepers with a luxurious sleep experience. From the Celliant® fibers to copper cooling, customers love these mattresses for their superior cooling, muscle pain relief, and balanced back support.
Birch Living
Birch Living is an organic mattress brand by Helix, which is one of the most popular mattress in a box companies. After merging with popular mattress company Brooklyn Bedding at the end of 2021, Birch Living mattresses are now made in a Arizona and feature all-natural and organic comfort layers with pocketed coil support systems. With a focus on back support and 'ergonomic pressure relief,' there is a lot to love about these natural mattresses.
Based on our aggregated reviews and our scoring method, we recommend Bear Mattress in this match up!
See Our Full Review of Bear Mattress
Mattress Score
Overall Score:
Bear Mattress: 9.5/10
Birch Living: 9.3/10
Customer Satisfaction:
Bear Mattress: 9.5/10
Birch Living: 9.3/10
Price Value:
Bear Mattress: 9.4/10
Birch Living: 9.3/10
No Back Pain:
Bear Mattress: 9.6/10
Birch Living: 9.3/10
Price:
Bear Mattress: $786-$4996
Birch Living: $1373-$3123
Bear Mattress:
Get 35% Off + Gifts | Code slumber35
Birch Living:
Get 20% Off + 2 Free Pillows
Bear Mattress's Owner Satisfaction
Going over reviews is a great way to shop for a new mattress because you increase your chances making a good purchase. Based on the recent review and sentiment data, customers rate these mattresses as some of the highest performers. So, feel confident diving into this brand more!
Bear Mattress's Supportiveness
Support is essential for a good night's sleep, and reviewers definitely signal that these mattresses are some of the most supportive. Sometimes supportive is used to mean firm, but medium or soft mattresses can be supportive too. The big difference between a supportive mattress and one that's not is if it supports and facilitates a healthy spine. These mattresses provide lasting excellence at providing that kind of support.
Edge Support
Do you want a mattress that provides a comfortable ledge to sit on? These mattresses provide a great seating position for you to put on socks or slippers.
Bowling Ball & Density Tests
Many folks like to measure mattresses by the bowling ball test, which shows the mattress firmness. It is essential to have even support across the mattress to align the spine. These mattresses give even support across the mattress for a properly aligned rest.
Bear Mattress's Durability
One of the most essential things for mattress buyers is durability. Getting 7 to 12 years out of your mattress is good in terms of durability. That said, there are other things that affect durability -- like material quality and sleeper size. These mattresses do very well when it comes to durability. However, some folks that have heavier bodies may find a slight decrease in longevity.
Birch Living's Owner Satisfaction
It's not always easy figuring out what mattresses score well on customer satisfaction versus others. Based on our analysis of online customer sentiment, customers rate these mattresses very well. Even though you may not necessarily share the same love after buying, these mattresses are worth a look over. Read on below for more information.
Birch Living's Supportiveness
These mattresses are quite supportive. These mattresses are good at supporting the back and keeping things well aligned for the hips and shoulders.
Edge Support
These mattresses also are competitive with their edge support, which is how good a mattress is supportive along the sides. For those that want to sit on the side of the mattress to put on socks or slippers, these mattresses will provide a good amount of resistance for you.
Bowling Ball & Density Tests
Setting a bowling ball on your mattress is a good indicator of firmness, and it is also useful in seeing if the firmness changes in certain places in the mattress. It can show if there is an uneven surface. Based on this, these mattresses will do well in their even support of the spine.
Birch Living's Durability
Having a mattress that lasts a long time can means thousands of dollars in your pocket. It's one more great reason why durability is top of mind for mattress buyers. However, unsurprisingly, there are lots of brands that are more concerned with their immediate bottom line. In spite of that, there are still some great brands that make durable products. These mattresses are highly regarded when it comes to longevity. Unless you are of a heavy build and use the mattress more than average, these mattresses should perform for you for 7 - 12 years.
Browse Bear Mattress Customer Reviews
Sleeping like on a cloud!
This mattress is simply amazing! I immediately fell asleep and woke up nice and rested, no back pain what so ever! Like I said - amazing! I recommending this to everyone!
Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews
Perfect fit for me, maybe not for others
Took me a week to get my body use to the new bed, now it is amazing, I would suggest giving this bed some time before you make a final decision
The best!
My girlfriend and just got a Cal King and love it. Shipping was fast and the mattress is amazing. I should have done this years ago.
Great for her/bad for me
I was so excited to get my new Bear mattress, I know 2 people who have them and so I thought if they love them I'll get one. Worst 2 1/2 weeks ever. Woke up all night with a sore back and pain in my hips. But on the other hand my wife loved it. That's why I'm giving this a 3 star and not a 1, because I guess I like soft mattresses. This has about ...Read Morea 6 1/2 out of ten on the firmness scale which I thought was soft (it's not). I'm returned it and exchanged it for a softer mattress... Which I love. Best night sleep I've ever gotten, and she still loves it too. Read Less
Best Mattress for Anyone
My fiancé and I are not athletes by any means, but I'm a light sleeper and he moves around A LOT. We loved the fact that this bed had almost zero motion transfer. It's done wonders for me in getting a full nights sleep, and my fiancé loves it too. The only thing I'd say is that we wouldn't have probably found this company without watching review videos first. They seem to market to athletes a lot, but honestly this will work for anyone. Also the upgrade from a queen to a king is incredible. Thank you bear! We are customers for life.
Don't know that I believe in the Celliant technology
But after owning this for around 3 months, I have to say that this is the most comfortable mattress I've ever slept on. I used a Tempurpedic for a while, and I find the firmness of this mattress to be much better. This mattress may be too firm for some and too bouncy for others (I wouldn't want to try the bowling ball and wine glass test), but for me it seems to be just right.
Best sleep in months
We were hesitant to try the box memory foam mattresses at first, but after doing some research we decided on the bear mattress. The purchasing and delivery process was informative and quick. Setting up the mattress and foundation was very easy. My husband and I have slept very well since getting the mattress. I used to wake up in the middle of the night and toss and turn for hours before falling back asleep. I have slept through the night in a deep sleep for the entire month that we've had our bear mattress. We are very satisfied customers!!
Great nights sleep!
I am so glad gave this mattress a try! It took me about a week to adjust, but have been sleeping better than I have in a long time. Just the right blend of firmness, support and it really does conform to your body.
Good night sleep
As advertised this is a very comfortable bed. The only thing I have trouble with is that I lay too long in one position on my back it can be uncomfortable but I don't think it is the bed
Very comfortable bed! Relieved my
Very comfortable bed! Relieved my shoulder and back pain within a month
Excellent
Great mattress! Especially for the price. Sleep soundly and can’t tell when my husband gets out of bed. Mattress is firm yet molds to your body! Love it!
Ease and comfort
Bear mattress has been a great experience. It was so easy to order, came in just a few days and was very easy to set up. Now the mattress- super comfortable - just the right firmnes. I would definitely recommend and buy again!
Awesome!
Love this mattress. I am a very warm person and I have to say I love being cool all night long. We even bought the pillows and they are amazing. I would have to say I feel the mattress for me is a bit on the firm side, so it did take some getting used to. But overall it has exceeded my expectations. And what's even better is its wife approved..... She loves it!
BestEver
Great mattress, comfortable and supportive. I love it
Great mattress
Great, comfortable bed.
Amazing!
To be honest, after the first night I was ready to get rid of it! It was extremely firm and my husband urged me to give it time. Now after a few weeks, it’s great! I didn’t think a mattress that came out of a box would be that comfortable. It feels firm to the touch, but once you lay down you’re transported to a cloud. Love it!
Supportive nights sleep!
I've loved my bear mattress! It does not sleep warm at all. Sleeps cooly like a traditional mattress. The mattress is soft to the touch but very supportive and firm. I have not woken up aching since I got my Bear. Worth every penny!
Awesome
exceptional mattress/foundation. Has helped my sleep immensely
Bear Mattress
I bought my son the Bear Mattress and he is so happy he hates to get out of bed to start the day. I think the bed is amazing also and may get one for myself.
Great!
Great mattress! Sleeps really well and I love how cool it sleeps. I hope it never wears out but if it doesiwill buy another Bear!!
It's a little firmer than
It's a little firmer than I expected at first, my wife too. But after a few days you adapt to that and it really is a comfortable mattress. Love how it give that memory foam contour without that memory foam grab.
Bear Mattress- King
We love our Bear Mattress! It was super easy to set up, and super comfortable. It took a week to get used to, but after that we have never slept better.
New Mattress
We were looking for an affordable memory foam option mattress and wanted to upgrade to the king size! Definitely very happy with our purchase! Easy to set up and comfortable from the first night. My husband I noticed we slept a little “hot” the first few nights we had the mattress. We got use to it in about a week or so and have been enjoying it s...Read Moreince! (we live in San Diego so the weather doesn’t change too much) Good price and great quality! Read Less
Too firm for me
If you like a firm mattress, this one is for you. I was very pleased with the price and delivery. The mattress is also very nice, it's just too firm for me. Unfortunately, I will be returning it.
Very impressed with my Bear Mattress
The mattress has been great. The best mattress I've ever slept on. My big thing was the ability to dissipate heat while I sleep. if it could live up to that promise, I knew it would be perfect for me, and they actually pulled it off. Who needs a $3-5k Tempur Pedic? Get a Bear and you will not regret it. Evander Smart Founder of Bitcoin University
Hibernation Station
I used to prefer sleeping on a rock hard Select Comfort mattress. The Bear Mattress felt a little soft initially, but I got used to the memory foam feel. It provides good lumbar support and sleeps relatively cool.
Awesome!
I don't really know what I expected honestly, but I'm not disappointed! For the first time in years I woke up and walked to the bathroom. I didn't hobble. I didn't take a few minutes to work through the soreness. There was no soreness!! I've also been on the hunt for a good pillow for years and this is it! No neck pain and keeps me cool. I have a very physically active job and crossfit at least 3 days a week. This mattress totallt aids in recovery
Great Mattress
Found this mattress by luck online. Purchased it for my son after many failed attempts and he loves it; hasn’t slept this comfortably in a while. Highly recommend the company and the mattress, trying to convince my wife to get one for us.
Love it!
I’ve been sleeping on this mattress for a month or so now, and I love it! I originally got it for our spare bedroom, but we loved it so much that we moved it into the master bedroom! Very easy delivery, fun to open up, and the mattress is awesome! Did I say that I love it?
Bear mattress review
Love it!!!! Haven’t slept this great in a long time!!
Sleeping Great
We're very happy with our bear mattress so far! Sleeping great and it doesn't hold the heat like our old Tempurpedic did.
fine
I haven't had an amazing experience, but I'm still hanging on. My other mattress was giving me back pain every night. Since I have slept on the Bear it has only slowly been getting less painful to sleep at night. I don't love how the edges completely sink when I'm sitting on the edge of the bed -I practically slide right off. I'm still waiting thi...Read Mores one out to see if it holds up or improves more long term. ??? It's fine, but not great. Read Less
My Bear mattress is the
My Bear mattress is the most comfortable mattress I have ever slept on. It definitely helps with my chronic lower back pain. The price is also so much less expensive than comparible mattresses
Sleeping Cool Now
I purchased the king size Bear mattress and have been sleeping cool. I have always been a hot sleeper. Wake up sweaty and hot. Restless nights as a result. Not anymore. Since getting the Bear I have slept cool! Sleeping cool means better nights sleep for me. Very comfortable too. A great product at a great value. Sleeping cool and sleeping longer now! Loving it!!
Believe it's a nice mattress, although perhaps not right for me
The mattress seems to be of high quality and good feel. I would put it in the same class of other mattresses of the same type (Casper or Leesa). While I'm not sure it's working for me (personal feel only), there is nothing about this experience that was particularly negative up to this point; I knew there would be a chance for this to happen buyin...Read Moreg a mattress sight unseen. 3 star rating simply because I don't believe I will be keeping it, although I think I'd have similar results with the other ship to home style foam mattresses. Read Less
Firm yet comfortable!
This is the first mattress I’ve ever invested in. It took me a couple days to adjust to it and now it feels like a perfect match. I’m use to mattresses being really bouncy so it’s a nice change. Definitely worth it. I also purchased the bear box and mattress protector.
With minor customization it’s perfect for me
I love my bear! As a side sleeper I determined I needed a bit more cush so I added a 2” foam latex topper and a quilted mattress pad. With these minor adjustments I now have the bed perfect for me. The firmness level of the mattress is probably perfect as-is for back and stomach sleepers. With this purchase I upgraded from a traditional spring, queen size to the Bear cal king. I’m tall - 6’2” - and I am celebrating that my feet no longer dangle over end of bed. I find the foam technology far superior to the spring type. I made my own platform out of pine boards.
We like our new mattress.
We like our new mattress. However it says its a queen size and it is smaller than our queen bed frame fairly significantly. It is comfortable and a little softer than I thought.
Great bed for in between
Great bed for in between soft and firm!
Fantastic!
The bear mattress is extremely comfortable. I have no complaints so far. It’s a perfect mix of firm and plush. Before the bear mattress, I was waking up with backaches. These backaches have completely disappeared and I look forward to a great night sleep every evening.
Browse Birch Living Customer Reviews
great mattress and service
It's only been a few weeks, but I love the mattress so far. I had some questions and customer service was a great resource.
Show More Reviews Show Less Reviews
Best purchase!
This our first time ordering a mattress that comes in a box - but we are pleasantly surprised!!
we shall see
to be determined!
natural mattress
I knew I wanted an organic mattress because I get worried about the smell from a lot of the foam beds out there. We stumbled on Birch and wanted to give it a try. So far it's been really good - zero smell. Feel is medium / medium firm.
No-brainer
It's my new favorite thing in my apartment.
Just what we needed
A lot more affordable than some of the other natural mattresses we saw in stores and just as comfortable.
Great customer service
I spoke with an agent who was very helpful. Steered me towards adding the pillwo top to help make the bed more plush.
Yassssssss!
OMG...this mattress is awesome
Best sleep
My girlfriend and I both really like the mattress so far. And I must admit I like the social cause too.
Unclear
I've had back pain for a long time and finding the right mattress has always been a big struggle for me. When the bed is too soft, I get pain in my lower back every monring. When it's too firm, I get pain in my upper back. Feels like a no win situation. I wanted to try the Birch mattress because I hadn't tried a bed with these materials yet. So fa...Read Morer it's been fairly good, but I'm holding on judgmenent for a few more weeks. Read Less
Side sleeper
I like the pressure relief on my shoulders
Dan
We got this mattress to replace our old dingy bed we had for years. It has a good amount of support on my back, and my wife enjoys it as well.
Super plush with the topper
Feels like a mattress you'd find in a fancy hotel with the topper. Really like it so far.
A little firm
It started off a little firm.
It's awesome.
Can I never leave bed again? Like, seriously?
Good so far
Great mattress, but also great company. Love the 1% donation policy. I've been sleeping on the mattress for a few weeks and it has the right amount of bounce, but also plushness.
Enjoyable
I like it so far, but need to give it a bit longer.
No more pain
Just the right amount of support for my back
Great quality
Transparency is key for me - it's not just about the mattress, but also the supply chain. I love that they are Rain Forest Alliance approved.
Support.
It has really good support and sink for a bigger guy like me. Heavy to carry up the stairs.
Love it
Holy wool - this mattress is insanely comfortable. You can really feel the wool as compared to other mattresses I've tried.
Love it!
Very comfy!
Thick enough to relieve nerve
Thick enough to relieve nerve pain in my leg.
Very comfortable
Very comfortable
Not for me
The mattress did not work for me. Thanks for trying.
Comfortable, but a bit firm
Full, disclosure, my prior mattress had a built in pillow top, so that’s what I’m used to. I do like this mattress a lot, but as a relatively small person (about 130 lbs) I don’t sink in as much as I’d like. It does seem to be getting better with time though.
Very happy
Noticeable improvement in my comfort level at night after getting this. Minimal odor which quickly dissipates. Very happy with purchase and would recommend to others.
Super organic!
The mattress did not smell at all when I opened the package! It's comfy, supportive, and breathable. Every time I have friends over I show it off to them and have them lay on it. The responses are always the same. "Wow!"
Best mattress I have tried
This is very comfortable with the added topper. Would buy again
Peaceful Sleep and Peaceful Mind
In these first couple weeks of sleeping on the Birch mattress I am waking up refreshed, not sore and tired as with my old mattress. We feel great about the sourcing and material of the mattress and the ease of the process and glad we purchased from Birch.
Still don't have my mattress on day 19 and they guess maybe sometime a week from now
This is a buy then build model. They have supplier issues. I don't have my mattress, but they DO have my money. when I emailed and DMd them their response is My guess is next week some time? If you don't need a mattress for a month or more and don't mind them taking your money before they give you a product then order away. But don't expect to hear from them or get any updates that are meaningful or useful when you "track" your shipment. Even though they know about their supplier problems they just keep advertising 5-15 days to delivery. I hope this honest review helps the next person.
best mattress ever
I was skeptical after some initial issues with customer service (wrong item sent initially & then delay in the shipment of correct item), but this mattress is incredible. I'm a chronic insomniac and this is the only mattress I've ever slept in that gives me a halfway decent night's sleep. I can't even begin to imagine what this does for folks Read more aboutwithout chronic sleep issues. One thing I want to note is that it is a lot softer than I expected. Maybe for people that are used to sleeping on super soft memory foam it will feel firm, but if you've been sleeping on a pretty firm mattress, this might feel too soft. The wrong item they initially sent was the mattress topper, which made it way too soft for my liking.
Worst Mattress Ever
This will make your back ache and the quality is terrible. My husband weighs 170 pounds and his side of the bed is sagging.; we've owned this bed for 6 months. We spent 1,600 dollars and regret every penny. Trying to get a refund now, but the company is not working with us.
Well this is not my
Well this is not my first natural latex bed, I wasn't that impressed at first I think mainly because of the springs. But that said we continued on with the test, it was cooler temp wise then our previous mattress which was the main reason I wanted to try this mattress. I eventually purchased a additional topper and at least for me that made a big ...Read MoreRead more about review stating Well this is not mydifference so I guess we're going to keep it. Read LessRead less about review stating Well this is not my
Awesome mattress!
My birch mattress is awesome. So incredibly comfortable. My son & his wife were visiting & I let them stay in my bedroom. They commented on their own how incredibly comfortable the birch mattress is. I highly recommend it.
Extremely comfortable, very quiet. The
Extremely comfortable, very quiet. The stronger springs on the edges make for a secure feel. Love it
Mattress is great. It feels
Mattress is great. It feels really good to lie on and is very comfortable. The firmness is perfect for our requirements. The best part is the support at the edges of the mattress, so you never feel like you're gonna fall off. Also the way the mattress is built, movements on the bed arent transmitted which is great for a good nights sleep! Highly r...Read MoreRead more about review stating Mattress is great. It feelsecommend! Read LessRead less about review stating Mattress is great. It feels
Great mattress
I love that, in addition to the firm support underneath a comfortably soft top layer, the mattress is made of safer, natural and nontoxic materials. The warranty is also really strong, which adds peace of mind. And unlike the last mattress we purchased that came compressed and rolled, the Birch relaxed to a perfect shape quickly and didn't have an...Read MoreRead more about review stating Great mattressy smell of chemical offgassing. Read LessRead less about review stating Great mattress
Side/stomach sleeper
Very happy with our first bed in a box purchase. I am mostly a side and stomach sleeper, and previously was feeling pressure points. The Birch bed has provided all the support I need as advertised. My wife sleeps more on her back, and agrees mattress was a great purchase. Also really appreciated not having to deal with VOC off gassing we experienc...Read MoreRead more about review stating Side/stomach sleepered with kids mattresses bought locally. Only negatives we noticed were minor: 1) the mattress being replaced went right to edge of Foundation, Birch mattress appears to be about 1” narrower (~1/2” of foundation visible on each side). 2) long lead time to receive, ~5-6 weeks from what I recall. Read LessRead less about review stating Side/stomach sleeper
Very comfortable. Love that is
Very comfortable. Love that is made in USA with natural products. Thanks!!